Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Other news

13 February 2006
Categories: News , Admin
AAT and ATT guidance on UITF 40; PricewaterhouseCoopers pantomime

More on UITF 40

The Association of Taxation Technicians and the Association of Accounting Technicians have published guidance on the effect of Abstract 40, issued by the Urgent Issues Tax Force in March 2005.
The ATT and AAT say that the guidance has been produced after discussions with the UITF and is not inconsistent with its own interpretation of the abstract and of application note G to Financial Reporting Standard 5. However, they add that the neither the UITF nor the Accounting Standards Board can endorse guidance which any professional body offers to its members.
The key points made by the guidance are:

  • there has been no change to the basis of valuation of stocks, work in progress or debtors;
  • in order to recognise revenue from an uncompleted contract, the entity must have reached a point where there is a right to consideration in respect of the work done to date;
  • if the right to consideration does not arise until the occurrence of a critical event during the contract, then revenue is not recognised until that event occurs. The incomplete assignment is then valued as work in progress at the lower of cost or its net realisable value;
  • however, for many entities there will be no ability to invoice until the immediate task is complete. In those circumstances an uncompleted contract will continue to be valued as work in progress.

The guidance concludes that 'in all cases, the policy to be adopted must be agreed with the client and applied consistently. The policy must be practical, and where changes to the policy occur, the resultant change must be material to the presentation of true and fair accounts. The basis adopted must not overstate the amount that a customer will accept and pay for services performed up to the year-end'. For details of the complete guidance contact the ATT, tel: 020 7235 2544, www.att.org.uk.
This guidance seems to fly in the face of comments made by the accountancy profession's umbrella group, the Consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies in its press release issued on 6 December 2005 responding positively to the Chancellor's agreement to spreading the additional tax liability arising from UITF 40.
In the aforementioned CCAB press release, Ian Morris said: 'Under UITF 40 many firms will need to recognise turnover in respect of ongoing professional work as that work progresses by reference to the proportion of the work completed, rather than only when contracts are completed. This will result in a one-off uplift in reported profits and a corresponding increase in the tax charge, without generating any additional cash to pay the tax'. Given that nothing else has subsequently been published changing this view, it would seem that the ATT and AAT's interpretation of the UITF 40 is somewhat different from that of the CCAB. Furthermore, their guidance is 'not endorsed' by the ASB, says Hans Nailor, technical director of the ASB. He further points out that the guidance is no substitute for reading UITF 40.
The ICAEW was reluctant to comment, but if only for the sake of the members of the various accounting bodies and certainly from the point of positioning to the Treasury, it would be helpful if guidance could be agreed soon.

Behind you!

The accountancy profession's few brushes with the world of the arts tends to have been as the butt of Monty Python sketches, but staff from PricewaterhouseCoopers have been putting on a different sort of show in recent weeks. The annual pantomime has now been running for 20 years and provides over 7,000 inner city children from various local schools and charities with a night out at the theatre.
This year's pantomime was Jack and the Beanstalk and proved a huge hit with the audience. The cameo in the show I attended was from John Whiting, senior tax partner and darling of the press, who admirably ad libbed his way through his lines and showed some latent dancing talent. He received strong support from Gerry Lagerberg, partner in forensic accounting. As Gerry also happens to be my brother-in-law, this gave me a rare chance to see him in prison garb dancing with a cow! I'll dine off this for years.
Contributed by Francesca Lagerberg, national tax director at Smith & Williamson

Categories: News , Admin
back to top icon