New consultations
Two consultation documents looking at the way HMRC deal with transfer pricing enquiries and rulings and clearances have recently been published by HMRC.
The document 'HMRC approach to transfer pricing for large business' looks at:
- ways in which HMRC can better target its transfer pricing enquiries and focus on the right issues;
- resolving transfer pricing enquiries faster, with an 18 month completion timetable as the norm;
- devoting more resources to transfer pricing with more specialist input.
The closing date for responses is 15 September 2007.
The other document, 'Giving certainty to business through rulings and clearances' considers:
- giving businesses who seek HMRC's view on significant issues both pre and post transaction, a binding view within 28 days; and
- providing binding rulings across all relevant taxes for businesses that provide clear plans for investment.
The closing date for responses to this document is 12 September 2007.
A third recent consultation document called 'Taxation of the foreign profits of companies' has been published jointly by HMRC and HM Treasury. In this document, the Government proposes various structural reforms, aimed at creating a more straightforward regime for tax foreign profits. The main proposals are:
- exempting from tax certain foreign dividends on shareholdings of 10% or more;
- implementing a new regime to replace the existing controlled foreign companies rules;
- restricting interest relief for international groups and extending the existing unallowable purpose rules applicable to loan relationships and derivative contracts;
- abolishing Treasury consents.
The latter proposal is welcomed by Deloitte's Bill Dodwell, who says that these consents date back to the time of exchange control and 'are widely viewed as anachronistic and burdensome'. He adds that the Government intends that the rules will be replaced by a reporting obligation. Responses to this document should be received by 14 September.
Chris Sanger of Ernst & Young says the exemption of foreign dividends 'is a positive move'. He adds that the proposed participation regime, which exempts tax profits from overseas subsidiaries from UK tax, 'should enhance the attractiveness of the UK as a hub for business investment'. However, he is concerned the consideration of the taxation of the profits of overseas branches is missing, saying that these need to be included in the participation regime so that 'businesses can be free to decide the best way to operate' rather than the tax system pushing them towards one direction.
Small businesses are excluded from the reforms. Bill Dodwell, although welcoming this, suggests that they too would have benefited from 'the administrative savings of dividend exemptions' and Chris Sanger says that it 'appears more to be an anti avoidance mechanism, seeking to protect the Exchequer'.
Copies of all the above consultations can be found at: www.hmrc.gov.uk/consultations/index.htm.
HMRC news release dated 20 June 2007







