No abuse
The Pirelli appeal concerned advance corporation tax and group income elections and had been part of the Group Litigation Order ([2006] STC 548) that went before the House of Lords in February 2006 (see Update Taxation 16 February 2006 page 497 for a report of that decision). The case was remitted back to the Chancery Division where Pirelli raised a new point. It argued that the double tax agreement credit which the non-UK companies received and which Pirelli accepted should be considered in calculating the compensation should not be characterised as a double tax credit which those companies were not entitled to at all. If a group income election had been made the dividends paid to the non-resident companies would have been free of advance corporation tax.
HMRC said that raising a new point was an abuse of process since...
Please reach out to customer services at +44 (0) 330 161 1234 or 'customer.services@lexisnexis.co.uk' for further assistance.