Where a person who had incurred a penalty died, TMA 1970, s 100A(1) allowed HMRC to impose the penalty on the personal representatives of the deceased. HMRC now accept that s 100A(1) was incompatible with Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights, and FA 2007, Sch 24 para 29(b) repealed s 100A(1).
In view of the uncertainty surrounding penalties sought under s 100A(1), HMRC undertook, in a letter which accompanied HMRC's acceptance of those personal representatives who offered to pay penalties, to repay the amount paid in respect of penalties, should the department or the courts decide that penalties arising from the default of a deceased taxpayer should not be imposed on the deceased's personal representative.
HMRC have written to those personal representatives who were sent this letter advising them repayment will be made. Advisers with clients who have entered into a settlement where the letter was issued, but have not been contacted, should advise HMRC's Pauline Howell, tel: 0161 475 2715.







