Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Data losses should star in 'table of shame'

03 January 2008
Categories: News
Every misplaced return would count against Revenue, suggests tax expert

Future data losses should have severe legal consequences for HMRC, advises a new Justice Committee report.

The paper remarks that the Revenue's much-publicised loss of 25 million individuals' confidential details was not 'an isolated example'.

It also notes that there is a 'widespread problem within Government relating to establish systems of data protection'. 

But the report's recommendation that reckless or repeated breaches of security be treated as criminal offences is a step too far, claims tax expert Rebecca Cave.

She believes that such crimes would be 'unenforceable, in the same way that corporate manslaughter is unenforceable: it's impossible to be sure who's to blame'.

However, Rebecca, an experienced tax accountant and writer, agrees that strong action must be taken to put a stop to such errors as last year's loss of child benefit records.  

She suggests an annual 'league table of incompetence' for all public bodies, with each misplacement of a tax return regarded as a point against HMRC.

Tax advisors would be allowed to go on record every time they reported a loss by the Revenue of a client's paperwork.

This would be carried out in a similar fashion as when accountants report clients who fail to comply with tax laws.

Figures would soon add up, claims Rebecca, because it is not unusual for one client's return to be misplaced by HMRC two or three times.

'Every single piece of information is important', she says. 'It's not just the multiple losses that should be reported.

'The Revenue would certainly sit up and take notice if their security breaches were published each year.'

Rebecca believes that a 'table of shame' would lead to the department taking data losses 'far more seriously'.

 

Categories: News
back to top icon