Now that the dust is starting to settle on 'the great tax crash' of 31 January as The Times describes it, we are trying to ascertain the reasons for the failure of HMRC's self assessment online filing service, its effects and the lessons that can be learned.
We have been unable to ascertain the exact reason for the failure of online filing on 31 January and await HMRC's further comments on this.
At the foot of this story is a link to a PDF of an error message printed from HMRC's website yesterday.
If any readers are able to shed light on possible causes, we would be interested in receiving these thoughts.
With regards to its immediate effects, HMRC issued the following statement on 31 January.
'HMRC's Self Assessment Online filing service has experienced technical difficulties this morning which has meant that some taxpayers have experienced difficulties filing on-line.
'The system is now rapidly returning to normal levels of service. A record number of 3.6 million taxpayers have already successfully filed on-line with 160,000 filing today, 10,000 more than filed on the same day last year.
'HMRC takes any disruption of service very seriously and to reflect this everyone who files electronically or by paper by midnight Friday 1 February will be treated as having filed on time.
'We very much regret any inconvenience this may have caused.'
On further enquiry, HMRC confirmed that the expression 'treated as having filed on time' will mean that the enquiry window will not be extended by a further three months as would normally be the case.
This is in addition to the widely reported 'concession' that a £100 penalty would not be charged in respect of tax returns filed on the 1 February.
The online filing figures have been updated today and we are advised that a total of 205,000 returns were filed online on 31 January, 55,000 more than last year.
However, we have not yet been able to obtain details of how many were via third-party software and how many by way of HMRC's online service.
Looking to the future, in response to our question regarding the new filing requirements in FA 2007, HMRC confirmed that they had no plans to defer the paper return filing deadline of 31 October 2008 for 2007-08 tax returns to allow a back-up filing system in the event of a similar failure on 31 January 2009.
HMRC advised Taxation that the department is planning to spend a further £150 million updating the online system.
Unfortunately, this was on the same day that The Times announced that HM Treasury plans a major review 'to ensure better value for money' for future IT projects.
Bearing in mind previous system failures, there will also no doubt be concerns in the profession as to whether the filing system is 'bulletproof'.
As of 1 February the answer must be a resounding 'no' and practitioners will remember the warning in Lord Carter' s 'Review of Online Services' which stated (paragraph 23):
'We recommend that as part of their work to deliver robust, high-capacity services HMRC should build in more rigorous testing.
'Each of the services should be capacity tested at least a year before our recommendations are implemented, and if any tests are not successful the measures relating to that service should be deferred.'
It would seem that HMRC intend to ignore this advice.







