Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

P35 warning for service companies

12 May 2008
Categories: News , Admin , Income Tax
HMRC 'keen to target' freelancers and contractors, claims tax services provider

HMRC has been criticised for creating confusion with this year's Employers' Annual Return for PAYE, which a major tax services provider claims has been amended to 'target' service companies.

Abbey Tax Protection believes the intention of the P35 form's first part of guidance question six — 'Are you a service company' — has been designed to split employers into two distinct categories: those who employ only the main shareholder or shareholders, and those whose income is earned by its workforce but do not control the company.

The company went on to state the belief that HMRC is 'keen to target' people in included in the first category: freelancers and contractors who have the ability to save tax and National Insurance by paying themselves a small salary and large dividends.

'Despite HMRC's contentions that they were not going to use the answers to question six to risk-profile individual employers,' said Abbey Tax, 'this can be the only sensible reason for having the question in the first place'.

'HMRC has said that those businesses who have answered the form incorrectly need not amend it but we can be fairly confident that this concession will not apply in the future.'

The tax services provider then voiced its conviction that the Revenue will use the information in gleans via Q6 to start enquiries into service companies.

'We would not be surprised to find [HMRC] selecting those companies where the shareholders are paying themselves the basic minimum salary, to avoid any tax or NIC, and taking the rest as dividends.'

Abbey Tax consultancy manager Paul Mason said: 'HMRC have been forced into correcting misleading guidance in its PAYE P35 information to employers.

'For many employers it's simply too late: they've been confused into providing unnecessary information that HMRC will undoubtedly use to target individuals, particularly in the service industry, for risk-profiling and tax investigations.'

Last month, the Revenue responded to concerns about Q6, admitting that it had caused considerable confusion and apologising for the matter.

Categories: News , Admin , Income Tax
back to top icon