Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Doubts over Tax Credit losses

15 July 2008
Categories: News , Income Tax
HMRC errors 'may be more than suggested'

HMRC may be responsible for a greater amount of Tax Credit losses than has been suggested, believes the Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG).

The department has estimated that it lost between £1.31 billion and £1.54 billion through a combination of fraud and error during the 2006-2007 tax year (7.2% to 8.4% of the final value of awards). However, the new National Audit Office (NAO) report in which the numbers appear does not provide separate figures for chicanery and blunders.

But it does show that the Revenue has estimated that, in the same period, 'official errors' led to £30 million being paid to unauthorised Tax Credit claimants, while £50 million failed to be awarded to legitimate claimants.

The LITRG remarked: 'We suspect that HMRC error is more prevalent than they claim' and it added that 'there is a fundamental difference between [fraud from error] - and the reasons why each occurs should lead to different remedies'.

The organisation went on to criticise the NAO document for being 'short on analysis as to why the claimant error component gives rise to what are undoubtedly extraordinarily high sums of money'.

The LITRG suggested that the figures estimated for HMRC error were 'on the low side' because there is 'a high proportion of tax credit overpayments where HMRC initially assert that they are correct, but which are eventually written off due to official error'.

'We are not confident that HMRC processes for distinguishing between claimant and HMRC error are sufficiently robust.'

The department has set a target to reduce the current level of claimant error and fraud by 2011 to no more than 5%. It is also strengthening its response to claimants who represent the highest risk of error and fraud, as well as considering other measures that are currently being trialled.

HMRC plans to use the results of the pilot schemes to focus compliance activity on areas that most effectively reduce error and fraud

The LITRG, however, fears that such a move would 'slow down normal claimant processes and require more people on low incomes to justify what they have put on their forms'.

Categories: News , Income Tax
back to top icon