Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Customs news

16 June 2005
Categories: News , HMRC powers
Business Brief 12/05 dated 15 June 2005

Aligning VAT accounting periods

HMRC have a discretionary power in regulation 25 (VAT Regulations 1995) to align VAT periods between the associated businesses, thereby removing the cashflow benefit. They may exercise that power by either withdrawing existing permission for monthly periods or by directing a variation to accounting periods. HMRC intend to continue to exercise this power where there is little or no commercial rationale for the VAT period 'stagger' between the associated businesses besides obtaining the cashflow advantage. They may do so, notwithstanding that the usual policy for businesses expecting to make regular claims for repayment of VAT in other factual situations is to allow monthly returns.
HMRC say that they have no intention of using these powers except in cases where a significant cash flow advantage arises and there is a need to protect the revenue.
There is no right of appeal to the VAT tribunal against the use of the regulation 25 powers, although the use of the power is subject to judicial review.
Business Brief 12/05 dated 15 June 2005.

Share issues

HMRC have updated their position on the VAT treatment of share issues and subsequent input tax recovery, following the decision in Kretztechnik AG v Finanzamt Linz (Case C-465/03). In this case, the European Court of Justice ruled that the issue of shares by a public limited company is not a supply and that the VAT incurred on the costs is recoverable to the extent that the company's outputs are taxable transactions.
Until now, HMRC's treatment of share issues has been guided by the Court of Appeal decision in Trinity Mirror plc v CCE [2001] STC 192. This had established that the issue of shares in the UK by a company for the purpose of financing its business was an exempt supply under VATA 1994, Sch 9 Group 5 Item 6. Any input tax that was attributable to the costs of making the issue was therefore generally not deductible. Kretztechnik has established that this treatment is incorrect.
Companies that make a first issue of shares in circumstances that are the same as those in Kretztechnik are now entitled to recover the input tax incurred on the costs of the issue to the extent that they make taxable supplies. Therefore companies with wholly taxable outputs will be entitled to recover all of the relevant input tax, while those with both exempt and taxable outputs will be entitled to recover a proportion in accordance with their partial exemption method. Claims for input tax in respect of past share issues will be accepted subject to the three-year 'capping' rules.
With regard to other situations in which a company may issue shares, e.g. as part of a company merger, demerger or other restructuring, HMRC are taking legal advice on the extent to which Kretztechnik applies to such situations and further guidance will be issued to businesses after this advice has been received. Any claims for repayment received in the interim will be acknowledged but not processed until this advice has been received.
Similarly, HMRC are obtaining legal advice on whether or not transactions involving issues of financial instruments and securities other than shares are affected.
Business Brief 12/05 dated 15 June 2005.

Landlord inducements

HMRC have revised the guidance on the VAT status of inducement payments by landlords to tenants. This replaces earlier guidance in Business Brief 04/03, dated 27 May 2003.
Following representations and discussions with various bodies, HMRC now accept that lease obligations, to which tenants are normally bound, do not constitute supplies for which inducement payments on entering leases are consideration. The majority of such payments are therefore likely to be outside the scope of VAT as they are no more than inducements to tenants to take leases and to observe the obligations in them. There will be a taxable supply only where a payment is linked to benefits a tenant provides outside normal lease terms. However, merely putting such a benefit as an obligation in a lease will not mean it ceases to be a taxable transaction.
It is considered that this change of policy now effectively puts inducement payments on a similar VAT footing to rent free periods, in being mainly outside the scope of VAT and only a taxable consideration when directly linked to a specific benefit supplied by a tenant to a landlord.
Examples of taxable benefits by tenants that may be supplied in return for such inducements are:

  • carrying out building works to improve the property by undertaking necessary repairs or upgrading the property;
  • carrying out fitting-out or refurbishment works for which the landlord has responsibility and is paying the tenant to undertake;
  • acting as anchor tenant.

The policy change referred to above may mean that there have been certain cases where tax has been charged wrongly in respect of landlord inducements under the guidelines in Business Brief 04/03.
Tenants who have wrongly declared output tax on inducements received are not obliged to adjust their VAT position, but if they choose to do so will be subject to the three-year capping provisions.
Business Brief 12/05 dated 15 June 2005.

Categories: News , HMRC powers
back to top icon