Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

New queries: 19 November 2026

16 November 2026
Issue: 5058 / Categories: Forum & Feedback

Can we submit return based on limited time period?

One of our clients exceeded the compulsory sales registration threshold temporarily in September 2023 but would have been entitled to deregister in May 2024 because she decided to work fewer hours from 1 June 2024 onwards. We concluded that a ‘liable not liable’ outcome was correct, ie my client had a VAT liability from 1 November 2023 until 31 May 2024, and wrote to HMRC on this basis, requesting a temporary registration. We attached form VAT1 with our letter.

It seems that the letter has been ignored because my client has been issued with a VAT registration number and a first return online for the period from 1 November 2023 until 31 October 2026. My thinking is that we should submit this return but only include figures for the period from 1 November 2023 until 31 May 2024 and then request deregistration from 1 November 2026. In other words, we reach the correct result in terms of VAT payable but by an unorthodox approach. What do readers think?

Query 20,819– Juggler.

New build or extension?

My clients’ home is a detached house on a corner plot. There are two single garages attached to the house side by side. Beyond the outer garage is a garden facing the road.

My clients want to build a house for their adult son, still living at home, in that garden. Because the plot is small, the house will need to be attached to the outer garage. That garage will be transferred to the son as part of the plot on which the house is built, so that the two houses will have one garage each.

My concern is the VAT zero rating of the new-build house.

  1. Am I right that the new house can be zero rated even if built right up against the garage, but that if an internal door is provided between them, it would no longer qualify?
  2. If so, what would be the consequence if the house was initially not internally connected, but the internal door was put in some time later?
  3. Alternatively, if the garage was demolished except for the party wall and one other, and the garage was then rebuilt as part of the new build, would zero rating still apply even if the new garage was identical to the old?

Query 20,820– Grand Designer.

 

Situs of OCC-issued US equity options

I would like to ask readers about the new four-year foreign income and gains (FIG) regime and how the situs of standardised US exchange-listed equity options should be determined under TCGA 1992, s 275A and s 275B.

Consider a qualifying UK-resident individual trading Options Clearing Corporation (OCC)-issued, US exchange-listed options over shares that are themselves situated outside the UK. A UK-regulated introducing broker maintains the retail client relationship under an English-law customer agreement, while a US carrying/clearing broker intermediates the transactions. The options are governed in their creation, exercise, assignment and clearing by the US exchange/OCC framework.

Is the relevant asset for situs purposes the underlying standardised option (and rights inherent in it), or can rights under the separate UK-law broker/customer agreement cause any right or interest forming part of that option asset to be governed by or enforceable under UK law within the meaning of s 275B? Would the conclusion differ if an otherwise identical OCC option were traded through a non-UK broker?

I appreciate that the answer may depend on the particular contracts and legal rights held by the client. Are there any relevant HMRC manuals, decided cases or professional analyses that clarify how to distinguish the option rights from the broker’s service and consumer-protection obligations for this purpose?

A response referring to the statutory language or authorities would be especially helpful. This is a general technical enquiry rather than a request for a personal tax ruling.

Query 20,821– Interested.

Australian disability support pension

My client arrived in the UK in 2015. His son (a dependent adult under pension age) is in receipt of a personal independence payment (PIP) for his special needs in the UK. However, prior to arrival in the UK, he was also eligible for and received the Australian disability support pension (DSP) – the equivalent to PIP in Australia.

Despite now being a resident of the UK, the son is still entitled to the DSP. The son is also in paid part-time employment here in the UK, for which he is paid approximately £76 a week.

The guidance on the taxation of the DSP in the UK is very thin and confusing. Have readers had any practical experience of the DSP in the UK? Is it exempt from UK tax or taxable income?

Query 20,822– Alice Springs.


Queries and replies

Send queries and replies to taxation@lexisnexis.co.uk. Replies should be submitted by Monday, 11 days after print publication. We pay £40 for each reply published in the magazine and select those which reflect the widest range of answers. As a result, the views expressed are not necessarily our own and so they should be read with a critical spirit. Contributions may be identified by name or a pseudonym. For full T&Cs visit: tinyurl.com/authorTandCs.

Issue: 5058 / Categories: Forum & Feedback
back to top icon