Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Update - Revenue news

13 November 2005
Categories: News
NICs payable on fees of freelance musicians; Stamp Taxes Online

Chaotic concerto

HMRC have recently decided that Class 1 National Insurance contributions are payable on the fees of freelance musicians. The Association of British Orchestras says that the 'industry has never made such payments for its freelance musicians and was unaware of any such potential liability'. According to the association's recent press release, until recently HMRC had not demanded such payments and 'several inspections have taken place that appear not to have identified any liability'.
The rules in question were changed in 1998 at the request of the actors' union Equity to enable non-working actors to claim Jobseekers Allowance. The Musicians' Union and the Association of British Orchestras say that, unlike actors, musicians are very rarely unemployed and so wish to maintain their Class 2 or 4 payments.
As mentioned above, between July 1998 and April 2003, regulations were introduced (see HMRC's Employment Status Manual para ESM 4145) which treated most entertainers as employed earners regardless of whether they were employed under a contract of service or in an office with emoluments chargeable as employment income and therefore liable to Class 1 National Insurance. However, in 2003, see ESM 4147, HMRC decided that these regulations 'were no longer sustainable'. HMRC found that most entertainers entered into contracts which provide for residuals and royalty payments as part of their remuneration which exceeded the basic salary element, so that very few entertainers' earnings consisted 'wholly or mainly' of salary. Thus the regulations did not achieve the object of bringing most entertainers into employed earners employment. So HMRC introduced new regulations from 6 April 2003 which, instead of the 'wholly or mainly' salary criteria, 'ensured that an entertainer who receives any salary element in his remuneration would be treated as an employed earner for NICs purposes. Once subject to the regulations, there will be a liability for Class 1 NICs on all earnings from the engagement (including residuals and royalty payments)' (ESM 4147).
The backdated National Insurance contributions being discussed with HMRC would have a 'devastating effect on all British orchestras', according to the association. Estimates suggest that the sector could owe £33 million, and that the imposition of Class 1 contributions from April 2006 would run to approximately £6 million a year.
The association is 'extremely concerned at the un-joined up thinking between the Treasury and Department for Culture, Media and Sport which has seen one department, by way of the Arts Councils, investing £35 million in the sector while another appears to wish to remove it'. Russell Jones, director of the association, says that it will 'continue its constructive dialogue with HMRC and work with colleagues at the Musicians' Union, Arts Council England and Department for Culture, Media and Sport to ensure that a satisfactory agreement is reached with HMRC'.
Interestingly, with regard to consultation, Horace Trubridge, assistant general secretary of the Musicians' Union, says that, unlike Equity, it has never lobbied for the right for its members to be able to claim jobseekers allowance and that it had not been consulted. More curiously, though, is why it has taken HMRC so long to decide that National Insurance is due on the musicians' payments, particularly given the association's comment that PAYE inspections have taken place since 1998. On 9 November, HMRC placed a notice under the 'What's new' section of their website saying that they had 'learned that a number of orchestras have not operated Class 1 National Insurance on certain categories of musicians since 1998'. Asked further about why it has taken so long for HMRC to tell the orchestras that they should have been paying Class 1 National Insurance, HMRC say:

'The Musicians' Union, the Society of Musicians and other interested bodies  were consulted prior to the change in legislation. It is apparent that the orchestras were aware of the change in the rules because they applied them  correctly in respect of those members of Equity whom they engaged. It was the orchestras' responsibility under the law to ensure that they complied with the legislation
'HMRC employer compliance teams audit employers' compliance on a risk-assessment basis. There are only 250-300 orchestras in the UK. The non-compliance of orchestras was not identified sooner through such audits because they comprise a tiny proportion of the 1.5 million employers in the country.'

The fact that orchestras form only a 'tiny proportion' of UK employers is irrelevant; HMRC should be doing its job properly. However, given the amount of tax lost and not chased across the board (see recent National Audit Office reports on self assessment and VAT), perhaps one should not be surprised that it has taken seven years for HMRC to decide that Class 1 National Insurance should be paid by the orchestras.


Online only

Advisers who use Stamp Taxes Online to complete SDLT returns must send the returns online, say HMRC. It is not a print and post service. If the completed online form is submitted by post this will cause more than one UTRN to be allocated to the same transaction.
Those who do not wish to send returns online can complete returns using CD ROM, third party software forms, or HMRC Stamp Taxes green and white forms.
www.hmrc.gov.uk

Categories: News
back to top icon