Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Update - tax case

13 November 2005
Categories: News
HMRC v Thompson

Wrong question

A self-employed taxpayer failed to pay Class 2 National Insurance for the period 5 June 1972 to 1986. Up to 1972 he had paid them, but in that year his marriage broke up with the result that he had to move. He did not inform the Department of Health and Social Security of his change of address and did not pay Class 2 contributions until 1986. An officer of the Board of Inland Revenue ruled that under Social Security Contributions (Transfer of Functions, etc.) Act 1999, s 8(1)(m), the taxpayer's failure to pay contributions was attributable to ignorance or error on his part which was due to a failure to take due care under Social Security (Contributions) Regulations 2001, reg 6.
On appeal to the General Commissioners, the Commissioners allowed the appeal, saying that the taxpayer had suffered a great disruption to this life and had not received any reminders regarding the contributions. He had subsequently ensured that required contributions were paid. HMRC appealed.
In the High Court, the judge said that the General Commissioners had misapplied the law by asking and answering the wrong question. Furthermore, even if they had asked the correct question, they could not have properly reached the conclusion which they had.
For a taxpayer to demonstrate failure because of ignorance or error, he had to show that he did not know about National Insurance regulations or his obligations there under. This he did not do.
HMRC's appeal was allowed.
HMRC v Thompson, Chancery Division, 8 November 2005

Categories: News
back to top icon