Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Update - PBR

11 December 2005
Categories: News , Income Tax
Anti avoidance; Film relief; Pensions; REITs; Income tax personal and age-related allowances 2006-07; National Insurance contributions 2006-07

Anti avoidance

The disclosure régime, introduced in Finance Act 2004, is to be extended. The Pre-Budget Report includes:

  • proposals to improve the effectiveness of the 'filters' for direct tax to ensure they reflect recent developments in avoidance behaviour;
  • the extension of the régime to cover avoidance risks across all of income tax, corporation tax and capital gains tax, allowing HMRC to take further targeted action against avoidance; and
  • that businesses will be required to provide information on direct tax schemes and arrangements devised 'in-house', within 30 days of implementation, bringing them more in line with the rule for promoters.
  • HMRC will be discussing the changes with stakeholders. The changes will be effective from April 2006 and will allow HMRC to continue to respond swiftly and proportionately to tax avoidance.

Commenting that the disclosure of tax avoidance scheme rules has 'broadly been a success', Smith & Williamson say that HMRC are 'concerned that the volume of disclosures has fallen sharply', thus the new measures 'are intend to counteract any behavioural changes which may mean schemes are slipping through the net'.


Film relief

Revised proposed levels of tax relief for the production of culturally British films were proposed in the Pre-Budget Report, with legislation for the 2006 Finance Bill. Small budget films, i.e. those costing £20 million or less, will receive an enhanced tax deduction of 100% of qualifying production costs with a payable cash element of 25%. HMRC say that this is worth at least 20% of qualifying production costs. Films budgeted over £20 million will receive an enhanced deduction of 80%, with a payable cash element of 20%, which HMRC say is worth 16% of qualifying costs.
The new relief will be introduced on 1 April 2006 and will apply to films beginning principal photography on or after 1 April 2006 and to films which start before then but are not completed by 1 January 2007 and, in the case of relief for film acquisition expenditure, provided the film is acquired before 1 October 2007.
Although in its July consultation document, HM Treasury proposed that the relief would only be available to a film producer, defined as the company which incurs all the production expenditure on the film and owns all rights in it on completion, it became clear that this term is used in a number of different ways in the film industry and that its inclusion in the legislation for the tax relief could create confusion. In addition, it would, in some circumstances, have excluded companies at whom the relief was intended to be aimed. The new régime will apply instead to film production companies rather than to film producers. A film production company will be defined as the company responsible for the principal photography and post-production stages of the film and for the completion of the finished film. The company will have to have an active involvement in the process of film making in order to exclude any company whose participation is restricted to providing or arranging the finance for film production activity.
Under the new treatment for film production expenditure, a film production company will be deemed to be trading as soon as it receives any film-related income or incurs any film production expenditure. Film-related income would include grants and subsidies, fees and other amounts received for making a film, such as sale proceeds or royalties. Film production expenditure would be that incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of producing the film.
The new basic treatment for film expenditure will start to apply at the start of film production activity. This contrasts to the current situation in which F(No 2)A 1992, ss 40A and 40B start to apply only when the film has been completed. This will allow long projects, such as animated films, to take advantage of the tax relief much earlier, while doing away with complex rules to deal with pre-commencement and abortive expenditure.
This proposed treatment will only apply to companies in order to ensure that partnerships can no longer become involved in film production to shelter their members' income from tax. Film acquisitions will be included in the regime for intellectual property from which films are currently excluded.
Welcoming the new film tax relief, Simon Palmer, tax partner at KPMG said that 'the new rules will favour those making a number of British films, with larger budget films being treated more generously than expected'. The fact that the new rules take effect from 1 April 2006 was just 'what the industry was hoping for'.
Smith & Williamson comment that by targeting the relief directly at film producers rather than investors who are not actively involved in the film production, the Government has 'put an end to film sale and leaseback schemes, which have relied on legislation which allows films acqusition costs to be treated as revenue rather than capital and on investment through a partnership'. However, other schemes that 'rely on generally accepted accounting practice rather than specific film tax reliefs are not affected'.


Pensions

In a remarkable about-turn, Gordon Brown said that self invested personal pensions (SIPPs) and all other forms of self-directed pensions would be prohibited from obtaining tax advantages when investing in residential property and certain other assets, such as fine wines, from 6 April 2006. This action was to ensure that tax relief is only given to those whose purpose in making the contribution is to provide themselves with a secure retirement income.
The legislation will apply to direct investment in residential property and in most forms of tangible moveable property, similar to what are currently called personal chattels in the regulations covering small self administered schemes and SIPP investments at SI 1991/1614 and SI 2001/117 respectively. It will also apply to indirect investment in prohibited assets that are a close proxy for direct investment and to other forms of indirect investment that could be used to get around the new rules for prohibited assets. An example of this would be residential property owned by a company in which a SIPP held 100% of the shares.
The legislation will define what is meant by 'residential property' and how the rules will apply to property that is used for more than one purpose. This will ensure, for example, that if a pension scheme buys a commercially used property, such as a shop, this will not be classed as a residential property merely because there is an unconnected flat above the shop.
However, the Chancellor is 'minded' to allow SIPPS to invest in genuinely diverse commercial vehicles that hold residential property, such as the proposed real estate investment trust.
Victor Dauppe, tax principal at MacIntyre Hudson, said that this change would be a 'huge disappointment to many who were hoping to use the vehicle to obtain a tax efficient investment in residential property' and said that it was akin to 'using a sledgehammer to crack a nut' just to prevent some taxpayers from financing a second home using pension tax relief. With regard to the timing of the announcement, he added that it was 'frustrating that the Chancellor should close this loophole of his own creation less than six months before the new pensions régime has effect'. John Riches, chairman of Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners' technical committee, described the Chancellor's change of heart as 'dramatic' and said it was 'unfortunate that the Government felt that such significant restrictions were necessary to this innovative pension reform'.
In addition, with regard to tax-free lump sums, legislation will remove tax advantages where lump sums are recycled back into funds in order to generate artificial levels of tax relief. This means that relief will be lost where the lump sum is used to buy another pension with the accompanying tax reliefs available. Although, as Smith & Williamson point out, 'it is thought that individuals will still be able to borrow to fund pension contributions and repay their borrowings with their tax-free cash'.

REITs

Draft legislation to establish real estate investment trusts (REITs) in the UK for inclusion in the 2006 Finance Bill is to be published, together with details of the tax proposals. The following key features will be included:

  • the régime will be open to companies, resident in the UK, that are publicly listed on a recognised stock exchange;
  • companies or groups that meet the UK REIT eligibility criteria as set out in legislation will not pay corporation tax on qualifying property rental income or qualifying chargeable gains; and
  • a requirement to distribute at least 95% of net taxable profits on rental income to investors, who will then pay tax at their marginal rate.

The Government does not want any overall loss of tax revenue as a result of the introduction of the UK REIT and will, in addition, announce final details of the conversion charge applying to companies joining the régime in the 2006 Budget.
Commenting on the measures, Hira Sharma, corporate tax director at Chiltern, said that the UK REIT would 'enable property to be properly accepted as an asset investment class'. She said that 'at its core, the shares in a UK REIT will represent an income stock whose success will be measured by the ability to deliver dividend yields'.
Ros Rowe, tax partner, PricewaterhouseCoopers said 'these tax efficient vehicles have been designed as listed companies which are UK tax efficient', but she said what companies needed to know was missing, i.e. how much the conversion charge would be. She suggested that when the legislation was published, 'UK companies should consider the cost benefit of paying the conversion charge upfront compared with future tax savings on income and gains'. Peter Beckett, real estate tax expert at Ernst & Young, hoped that 'the rules will be simple and clear enough to attract the private investment the Chancellor said he wanted in this area'.
The REITs proposals announced in the Pre-Budget Report indicate that the Chancellor is planning to solve the technical problems discussed in the March 2005 consultation by only allowing UK resident companies listed on a recognised stock exchange to qualify, according to PKF. The Treasury is concerned about tax leakage through excessive gearing or where non-resident companies or investors are concerned: it is only prepared to introduce REITs if they are tax neutral. Peter Penneycard, PKF's national director of taxes, says 'The Government's cautious approach to introducing REITs is hardly a surprise — the Chancellor cannot afford any more u-turns on tax incentives — but will another UK-centric tax régime be credible in the long term? One also wonders if the UK property market will really develop in the way the Government intends if all that happens is that existing major companies convert to REIT status. It is a pity that smaller, more innovative companies will be excluded — they might have shaken up the market and forced the bigger players to innovate'.
In connection with the Chancellor's comment about widening the investment in residential and commercial properties, Ms Rowe hoped that this would 'not herald a return to requiring REITs to invest in residential property' as this would make them much less attractive.


Income tax personal and age-related allowances 2006-07

 

2005-06

2006-07

Personal allowance (age under 65)

£4,895

£5,035

Personal allowance (age 65-74)

£7,090

£7,280

Personal allowance (age 75 and over)

£7,220

£7,420

Blind person's allowance

£1,610

£1,660

Married couple's allowance* (aged less than 75 and born before 6 April 1935)

£5,905

£6,065

Married couple's allowance* (age 75 and over)

£5,975

£6,135

Married couple's allowance* (minimum amount)

£2,280

£2,350

Income limit for age-related allowances

£19,500

£20,100

*Tax relief for the married couple's allowance is given at 10%.

 


National Insurance contributions 2006-07

Lower earnings limit, primary Class 1

£84

Upper earnings limit, primary Class 1

£645

Primary threshold

£97

Secondary threshold

£97

Employees' primary Class 1 rate between primary threshold and upper earnings limit

11%

Employees' primary Class 1 rate above upper earnings limit

1%

Employees' contracted-out rebate

1.6%

Married women's reduced rate between primary threshold and upper earnings limit

4.85%

Married women's rate above upper earnings limit

1%

Employers' secondary Class 1 rate above secondary threshold

12.8%

Employers' contracted-out rebate, salary-related schemes

3.5%

Employers' contracted-out rebate, money-purchase schemes

1%

Class 2 rate

£2.10

Class 2 small earnings exception

£4,465/year

Special Class 2 rate for share fishermen

£2.75

Special Class 2 rate for volunteer development workers

£4.20

Class 3 rate

£7.55

Class 4 lower profits limit

£5,035/year

Class 4 upper profits limit

£33,540/year

Class 4 rate between lower profits limit and upper profits limit

8%

Class 4 rate above upper profits limit

1%

 

Categories: News , Income Tax
back to top icon