It is over a year since HMRC published their guidance on the decision in Langham v Veltema [2004] STC 544, reported in 'Veltema — fair or not?', Taxation, 13 January 2005, page 334. The earlier guidance issued in December 2004 was aimed at helping self assessment taxpayers achieve finality when completing their 2004 returns. Further guidance has now been issued as Statement of Practice 01/06. It sets out the discovery powers of HMRC in connection with income tax, capital gains tax and corporation tax and deals particularly with entries in returns involving valuations, other judgmental issues and those based on a different technical view from that of HMRC. The statement of practice provides that 'Where taxpayers' interests in an asset [...] are similar, but not the same, any valuations agreed would not necessarily bind other taxpayers'. Peter Penneycard of PKF said 'It is a pity that HMRC did not take the opportunity to recognise that in a situation similar to that in which Mr Veltema was concerned, the professional valuation agreed between the company's valuer and the district valuer was just that, a negotiated compromise'.
The statement says that taxpayers should submit the minimum information necessary to disclose the (potential) insufficiency but not so much that the critical information is lost in the mass. Unless it is obvious, the significance of the information should be specifically drawn to HMRC.
It applies to all self assessment returns for individuals and partnerships from 1996/97 and for corporation tax returns for accounting periods ending on or after 1 July 1999. Can the protection in the closing words of TMA 1970, subsection 29(2) as amended and FA 1998, Schedule 18 paragraph 45, be used to prevent this retroactive effect, at least in respect of returns submitted before publication of that of the Court of Appeal on 29 March 2004 in Langham v Veltema? Mr Penneycard says that it will be interesting to see if any taxpayer takes up this point. However, he adds, other than the fact that the guidance is now a formal statement of practice and, therefore, slightly more reliable in future conflicts with HMRC, it takes us no further forward.
Nichola Ross Martin on AccountingWeb points out that after the part of the statement referring to capital items and repairs, it says:
'Taxpayers who adopt a different view of the law from that published as the Revenue's view can protect against a discovery assessment after the enquiry period. The return would have to indicate that a different view had been adopted by entering in the additional information space comments to the effect that they have not followed Revenue guidance on the issue or that no adjustment has been made to take account of it.'
She says that 'the only time that this type of situation has ever arisen is in the present day, and this is in relation to the settlement provisions'. She goes on to say that these are a 'unique set of circumstances in which HMRC says the Court of Appeal judgment (in the Arctic case) represents the law as it now stands, but has failed to adjust its advice on disclosure to taxpayers'. As to what advisers should do in the light of the statement, Nichola recommends that they 'read the guidance issued by the professional bodies, discuss it with your client, and apply your own judgment'.
www.hmrc.gov.uk







