Criminal prosecutions
HMRC issued a statement of their criminal investigation policy on their website towards the end of 2005. In essence, they say that while they prefer to use civil investigations, they reserve the right to conduct a criminal investigation where they believe it to be merited. Key points from the statement follow.
It is HMRC's policy to deal with fraud by use of the cost effective civil investigation of fraud procedures, wherever possible. Criminal investigation will be reserved for cases where HMRC needs to send a strong deterrent message or where the conduct involved is such that only a criminal sanction is appropriate. However, HMRC reserves complete discretion to conduct a criminal investigation in any case and to carry out these investigations across a range of offences and in all the areas for which the Commissioners of HMRC have responsibility.
Examples of the kind of circumstances in which HMRC will generally consider commencing a criminal, rather than civil investigations are:
- in cases of organised or systematic fraud including conspiracy;
- where an individual holds a position of trust or responsibility;
- where materially false statements are made or materially false documents are provided in the course of a civil investigation;
- where deliberate concealment, deception, conspiracy or corruption is suspected;
- in cases involving the use of false or forged documents;
- in cases involving importation or exportation breaching prohibitions and restrictions;
- in cases involving money laundering;
- where the perpetrator has committed previous offences/there is a repeated course of unlawful conduct or previous civil action;
- in cases involving theft, or the misuse or unlawful destruction of HMRC documents;
- where there is evidence of assault on, threats to, or the impersonation of HMRC officials;
- where there is a link to suspected wider criminality, whether domestic or international, involving offences not under the administration of HMRC.
When considering whether a case should be investigated under the civil investigation of fraud procedures or is the subject of a criminal investigation, one factor will be whether the taxpayer(s) has made a complete and unprompted disclosure of the offences committed.
However, there are certain fiscal offences where HMRC will not usually adopt the civil investigation of fraud approach. These are:
- VAT missing trader intra-community fraud;
- VAT bogus registration repayment fraud;
- organised tax credit fraud.
In similar vein, on 19 December 2005 Dawn Primarolo made a statement in the House of Commons about Hansard, clarifying its use in the light of the merged revenue departments. She said that HMRC had introduced a single procedure on 1 September 2005 which built upon and replaced procedures originating in the old Customs and Inland Revenue departments. She also referred to Code of Practice 9 which relates to these procedures. Taxation covered the new procedure in Chris Oates' article 'Hansard RIP', Taxation, 22 September 2005, page 686.
www.hmrc.gov.uk







