Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

News - Revenue news

03 April 2006
Categories: News , HMRC powers , Income Tax
Speak up! - HMRC powers, deterrents and safeguards; PAYE online; Unwelcome surprise - filing deadlines

Speak up!

Individuals and businesses are being asked to contribute to the review of powers, deterrents and safeguards for HMRC. The public consultation is the second phase of a programme designed to ensure that the powers underpinning the new department are fair, efficient and make it easy for people to meet their obligations and claim their entitlements. In particular, the aim is to strike a balance between having simple, accessible systems which help taxpayers, and having sufficient powers to tackle those who are deliberately non-compliant. This document, available under the 'What's new' section of HMRC's website, www.hmrc.gov.uk, includes a summary of responses to the first stage of the public consultation, launched in March 2005.
The deadline for submitting comments is 23 June 2006. Contributions may be made by e-mail to: Angela.Shore@hmrc.gsi.gov.uk or by post to: HMRC and the taxpayer, Room 1C/03, 1st Floor, 100 Parliament Street, London SW1A 2BQ.
The first phase of work looked at the overall approach to designing powers, deterrents and safeguards, as well as concentrating on the principal areas of mis-alignment between what was inherited from the predecessor departments. The forthcoming programme will focus mainly on the areas of major overlap, primarily the taxation of businesses involving income and corporation tax self assessment, VAT and PAYE. Having established the right powers, deterrents and safeguards for these areas, the review will go on to look at the scope for using these to create more generic approaches across the range of HMRC activity.
Francesca Lagerberg chairman of the Tax Faculty says this is a 'once in a lifetime opportunity' to help get HMRC's powers right. This latest consultation opens up the debate, giving everyone the chance to comment on perceived problem areas and offer improvements. She suggests that it is time to 'think radically' about whether or not HMRC need all their powers, how the review of powers will fit in with other reviews, e.g. the review on the tax tribunals, how it will link in with the tax law rewrite. Everything needs to be pulled together and this round of consultation gives taxpayers a real chance to have their say on a vitally important aspect of tax administration.
HMRC press release dated 30 March 2006


PAYE online

Employers who wish to view their P9s can click on 'view latest tax codes' from HMRC's PAYE online for employers page.
Agents can use the client search to select a client which will navigate to the PAYE online page for the selected client, and then they should select 'view latest tax codes'. To view notices that have been issued within the last seven days, the agent can select the link 'view your clients who have received notices within the last seven days'. This will navigate to the screen that displays a list of clients who have recently received notices. Selecting the tax code notices for a client will navigate to the P9s.
Employers and agents can subscribe to the 'notifications service' by which HMRC will send an e-mail advising that PAYE notices and reminders are available. To subscribe to this service select the link 'provide us with an email address' from the HMRC PAYE online service page.
www.hmrc.gov.uk


Unwelcome surprise

The proposals in Lord Carter's review of HMRC online services to bring forward the deadlines for filing self assessment tax returns to 30 September for paper returns and 30 November for online returns have caused a certain amount of consternation among the tax profession. It certainly seems extraordinary that HMRC have accepted these proposals with no discussion with those most affected, i.e. taxpayers and their advisers, particularly given all the angst over the timing of the original deadlines before self assessment was introduced in 1996.
The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England & Wales believes that the changes are unexpected, unwelcome and will have major consequences for those who prepare and file the tax returns. Frank Haskew, head of the ICAEW Tax Faculty says: 'It is very disappointing that this recommendation has been accepted by the Government with no debate and consultation. Such a fundamental change to the income tax filing system requires rigorous scrutiny and consultation as it has profound consequences for taxpayers and their agents. Far from assisting in spreading workload, this will significantly increase pressure on taxpayers and their agents. Many factors which prevent taxpayers from completing their returns earlier are outside their control. In particular, the proposed 30 September deadline for paper filing leaves unrepresented taxpayers with only six months to sort out their tax affairs and submit their return compared to the current ten month period'.
The Chartered Institute of Taxation is particularly concerned about the proposed deadlines because the preparation of returns can usually only begin after 5 July when information is provided by employers in the form of P11Ds. The pressure on agents to produce thousands of returns to these tighter deadlines may mean that large numbers of returns either miss the deadline or have to be submitted with estimates. Anne Redston, chair of the Institute's personal taxes says: 'There has been no consultation with taxpayers or agents on this measure. HMRC should first find out if this idea is practicable before they announce such a radical change. Consultations should precede decisions, not follow them'.
In similar vein, Iain Brodie, a chartered accountant in Scotland, considers that 'these proposals are completely unreasonable and would create tremendous difficulties for accountants and taxpayers'. He has written letters to Gordon Brown and Lord Carter explaining why he believes that the 31 January deadline should stay, and these letters are reproduced below.
Do other readers agree? Why not write to the Chancellor and let him know before the changes are enacted.
An article discussing Lord Carter's review will appear in a future issue of Taxation.


Copies of Iain Brodie's letters to the Chancellor and Lord Carter follow.

Dear Mr Brown

I write to you with regard to paragraph 7 of the Review of HMRC Online Services by Lord Carter of Coles, which was published yesterday and I was shocked to read the recommendation that the deadlines for filing self assessment income tax returns should be brought forward to 30 September for paper returns and 30 November for online returns.
As you are well aware, the current deadline is 31 January and it would appear that a significant number of taxpayers have difficulty in meeting this deadline and any reduction in the filing period will cause even more difficulties, both for taxpayers and for accountants, like me, who complete self assessment tax returns for clients and I complete around 200 such returns, which represents almost all of the work of my practice.
Currently, I have almost ten months available to complete and submit all of these returns and this is the amount of time, which is needed. It is normally the case that a number of clients are unable to provide me with the necessary information before December or January but, even if all of these clients provided me with the information earlier in the year, this would not permit me to submit all of the returns by 30 November as I am already busy between April and November completing and submitting the returns of clients who are able to provide me with the information more promptly. The months of December and January are always the busiest months of the year but I ensure that all of my clients' returns are completed and submitted by the due date of 31 January. This will normally involve me working late on weekdays and working all of the weekends during January in order to meet the deadline but, although this means that January is always a very stressful month and a deadline of 28 February would enable my workload to be spread more evenly throughout the year, I accept the deadline of 31 January as being reasonable and attainable. In addition, if it is necessary to work late and at weekends, it is preferable to do so during January when there are few alternative outdoor activities.
Many accountants like me, work on their own with no staff and specialise in the completion of self assessment income tax returns. I am sure that you will agree that it is important and necessary to spread the annual workload as evenly as possible throughout the year and the current system enables this to be managed reasonably over the ten month period up to 31 January, leaving only the months of February and March relatively quiet and available to carry out other work and administrative and preparatory work, which is not time sensitive. If all of the work involved in the completion of the self assessment tax returns had to be compressed into the eight month period up to 30 November instead of the current ten month period, I do not believe that this would be achievable for sole practitioners like me as there would not be sufficient hours in the day to complete all of the work in time and the stress levels would be intolerable. Where there is insufficient time available for work to be carried out, it may not be carried out as efficiently, possibly resulting in there being more errors in the tax returns and this would be most undesirable both for accountants and for HMRC. It makes no sense whatsoever to compel accountants who specialise in self assessment tax returns to be seriously overworked for eight months and left with little work to do in the other four months.
As I submit my clients' tax returns by internet filing in all possible cases, the deadline of 30 September would not normally apply to me. However, I do not consider that there is any justification in creating an even earlier deadline for paper returns as it is sometimes necessary to submit paper returns if the internet system does not accept a particular return. For example, I found it necessary to submit three paper returns in January this year, one being too complex for the HMRC Internet system to accept and two, where new clients could not be accepted onto the internet system, due to the HMRC procedures for adding new clients to my list, failing to function properly in January. Although I had intended to submit these returns by Internet, I had to submit paper substitute returns due to the failings of the HMRC system. This illustrates why the proposals to introduce an earlier deadline for paper returns and to stop accepting paper substitute returns are both seriously flawed.
I am not sure if the earlier deadlines are being proposed in the mistaken belief that all of the returns, which are submitted in January have been ready well before this and have been artificially held back. I cannot speak for others but I can assure you that each return, which I prepare is submitted as soon as it has been completed and approved by the client, and all returns, which I submit in January are submitted at that time as that is when they have been completed and approved. If it is the case that some firms of accountants are holding back returns until late January for internet submission when these returns were ready to submit at a much earlier date, this is an entirely different problem, which should be addressed in a different way in order to encourage all internet filers to file returns as soon as these returns are ready for submission. It is my belief that most of the returns, which are submitted in January are submitted as soon as they have been completed and it is not possible for them to be submitted any earlier.
Whilst I am speaking as a sole practitioner, I believe that individual taxpayers and larger firms of accountants will share my views. It can often take taxpayers some months to receive the information required for tax returns from employers, banks etc as items such as forms P60, P11D and interest certificates are not received until well after 5 April. Similarly, where business accounts require to be prepared, it takes time to finalise these accounts and many taxpayers who are working hard in their businesses do not have spare time available to gather together the various papers until much later in the year and it seems that the Christmas and New Year holiday period is a time when many taxpayers carry out this work. This still enables the taxpayers to pay the tax by the due date of 31 January and there does not seem to be any benefit in compelling these taxpayers to submit returns at an earlier date.
As far as larger firms of accountants are concerned, as they are involved in many other areas of work as well as income tax self assessment, it may be suggested that they reschedule other work in order to transfer staff to tax return completion duties between April and November. However, given that tax is a specialised subject, there will be a limited number of staff who are experienced in the completion of tax returns and the transfer of staff from audit and other work to tax duties may not be desirable.
I am appalled that the proposal to bring forward the deadlines has been introduced without any consideration being given to the impact on taxpayers and accountants and no justification has been given as to why such a change should be made when no benefits will result from it. HMRC literature and correspondence make reference to working together and improving customer service and the proposals do not achieve these aims. As taxpayers and accountants try to work together with HMRC and are the customers of HMRC, I urge you to take the views of these customers into account by retaining the current filing deadline of 31 January and rejecting the unworkable and unreasonable proposals to bring forward the deadlines to 30 September and 30 November.

 

Dear Lord Carter

I am extremely concerned about your proposal to bring forward the deadlines for filing self assessment income tax returns to 30 September for paper returns and 30 November for online returns and I enclose, for your information, a copy of a letter, which I have sent to the Chancellor of the Exchequer.
I understand that the main purpose of your report was to encourage an increase in the use of the online services provided by HM Revenue and Customs and I am personally happy to make as much use as possible of such services. I submit my clients' self assessment tax returns by online filing in all possible cases and I only submit facsimile paper returns where the HMRC online system is not able to accept an online return due to the complexity of the return or where the online registration system fails to operate properly and prevents me from submitting a return. Whilst I am prepared to accept proposals, which encourage greater use of online filing of self assessment tax returns, I fail to see why the greater use of online filing should be used as an argument for bringing forward the deadlines for filing returns. As you will be aware, the actual online filing of a tax return takes only a few seconds whereas the gathering together of the information required to complete the return and the detailed work, such as the preparation of business accounts, the carrying out of detailed capital gains tax calculations and the obtaining of all of the information from clients, can take a considerable amount of time and will continue to take a considerable amount of time irrespective of whether the returns are filed online or in paper format. As the basic preparation of the return is the main factor in determining the amount of time taken to complete and submit the return, there is no reason why a return will be able to be completed two months earlier in 2008 than is the case now. Similarly, there is no logical reason why a paper return can be completed and submitted at a date, two months earlier than an online return. I also fail to see any logic whatsoever in your proposal to discontinue the use of paper facsimile returns. If a taxpayer or accountant is not able to submit an online return for some reason, it is surely better for HMRC to receive a neatly printed facsimile return, which has been prepared by computer, rather than a paper HMRC produced return, which has been completed by hand and, which could well be difficult to read and which has been copied from a computer printed facsimile return, wasting the preparer's time in the process. I do not know whether or not you discussed your proposals with those who actually prepare and submit returns but as a preparer of many returns, I can assure you that your proposals to bring forward the filing deadlines cause me a considerable amount of concern. The amount of work, which I shall require to do to complete my clients' tax returns, will remain the same in the future as is the case now and, as I already file the returns online, your report does not provide any explanation as to how I shall be able to carry out all of my work in two months less than I do now. At present, many taxpayers find considerable difficulty in complying with the current filing deadline of 31 January and a significant number do not succeed in complying with this deadline and your proposal to bring forward the deadline will only worsen the situation.
From a theoretical point of view, the greater use of online filing might appear to shorten the processing period for tax returns but, in practice, it is only the period following the submission of the return, which is shortened and the period taken to complete the return prior to submission will remain exactly the same as before and this fact has not been taken into account in your logic.
I consider that your proposals are completely unreasonable and would create tremendous difficulties for accountants and taxpayers. I therefore urge you to reconsider your proposal and leave the filing deadline at 31 January.

 

 

Categories: News , HMRC powers , Income Tax
back to top icon