Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

News - tax case

12 June 2006
Categories: News
McLoughlin (SpC 542)

Matured entitlement

The taxpayer was employed by a partnership, Pontis Consulting, under terms agreed in a letter dated August 1992. The letter said that 'should the partnership be dissolved or sold during your term of employment then you will receive 2.5% of the proceeds after costs'. The business and other assets of Pontis Consulting were transferred to Pontis Consulting Ltd in May 1998. The taxpayer did not receive 2.5% of the proceeds, but was offered the chance to acquire shares in Pontis Consulting Ltd. On 18 March 1999, the taxpayer was allotted 1,118,232 B shares of one penny for which he paid £11,182. On 19 March, the shareholders agreed to sell their shares to Skillsgroup plc and the consideration attributed to the taxpayer's shares was £557,330. HMRC assessed the taxpayer on the basis that his employer had issued him with the B shares at undervalue, i.e. £557,330, being the price that they would fetch on sale to Skillsgroup the next day, less £11,182. HMRC said the sum was an emolument from his employment and taxable in 1998-99, the year when he subscribed to the shares and sold them.
The taxpayer claimed that the shares were issued to him not as a result of his being an employee, but because of his interest in the partnership and the right to receive 2.5% of the proceeds. This right was an inducement to his agreeing to becoming an employee and as such they were taxable under Schedule E in 1992.
The Special Commissioner agreed that the taxpayer's entitlement to the 2.5% of the proceeds originated in the 1992 letter, but until the partnership was dissolved this was not an immediate right. Two conditions had to be satisfied before the right matured and received a value: the partnership had to be dissolved, and the taxpayer had still to be employed under the terms of the 1992 letter.
In 1992, the right to 2.5% of the proceeds was an expectation, so it could not be an emolument arising in 1992. It also followed that the right could only mature if the taxpayer continued to work for the partnership and continued to be within the scope of Schedule E. The lump sum paid to the taxpayer in Shilton v Wilmshurst [1991] STC 88 was different in that it was a physical payment made as an inducement to the taxpayer to transfer to another club. The taxpayer in the instant case received neither payment nor money's worth in 1992 for taking up employment.
The right to 2.5% of the proceeds matured in May 1998 when the partnership was dissolved. The taxpayer's right was satisfied by the ex-partners, then shareholders in Pontis Consulting Ltd, when they issued B shares to him. The shares were capable of being turned into money and so his entitlement became an emolument of an amount to be determined. This was determined in March 1999 when he subscribed £11,182 for the B shares that were sold the next day for £557,330. HMRC was therefore correct in assessing the taxpayer to tax under Schedule E on £546,148 for 1998-99.
The appeal was dismissed.
Comment from Nigel Doran of Macfarlanes: This case is eminently appealable on the law though, given the somewhat restricted facts presented to the tribunal, the result might not be different.
The award of the right to 2.5% of the sale proceeds of Pontis Consulting was held not to be earnings, because it was a 'mere expectation' not capable of being turned into money (similar reasoning to that in Bootle v Bye [1996] STC (SCD) 58). But how did the tribunal know this? It is a question of fact. It requires expert evidence as to whether an investor would have been prepared to buy, or lend against, the right in 1992. The question cannot be decided by a legal analysis of the right as an expectation. Some people will pay good money for expectations.
The clearest statement of this principle is by Lord Reid in Abbott v Philbin 39 TC 82: 'If in fact this type of option is a kind of right which can be turned to pecuniary account, what more is necessary to make it a perquisite?' There is no suggestion that the right must have matured or vested. The only question is: can it be turned into money? Many employee share options (including the option in Wilcock v Eve [1995] STC 18) are only exercisable if some performance condition is met and then only if the employee is still in employment. They are 'mere expectations' but nobody suggests that share options are not immediately taxable earnings (absent any statutory exemption). Restrictions depress value, but rarely prevent the right being traded altogether.
Whether the taxpayer's acquisition of the PCL shares in 1999 constituted earnings depends on whether he acquired them in his capacity as employee or as holder of the 2.5% right. This in turn depends on whether the right was 'intimately linked with employment' (such as the trade union rights in Hamblett v Godfrey [1987] STC 60) or 'enjoyed in some other capacity” (as in Wilcock). Certainly, the 2.5% right was perfectly capable of existing independently of the taxpayer's employment (as an investment, like a share option). The growth in value of the 2.5% right between 1992 and 1999 seems to have owed at least as much to the 'adventitious prosperity' of Pontis Consulting (a phrase used by Viscount Simonds in Abbott) as it did to the taxpayer's employment.

Categories: News
back to top icon