Venturing forth
Refocusing the gross assets test will ensure that investment under venture capital trusts is 'directed to those companies that most need it and to where there is most clearly a market failure', said John Healey, Financial Secretary to the Treasury.
He explained that the new gross assets test had been set at £8 million and £7 million, because it had been shown that investment in companies with total assets of less than £8 million are higher in technology, business services and manufacturing. These are the higher risk sectors that the Government wishes to target. The risk was lower in companies with assets over £8 million, because such companies had collateral against loans so were less likely to experience the same problems that the smaller-sized companies had. Mr Healey said that the average size company invested in under a venture capital trust was £3.8 million.
It was suggested that the figures of £8 million and £7 million were arbitrary, but Mr Healey said that the Treasury was looking for 'effectiveness not elegance'.
With regard to the 70% or less rule, i.e. the stipulation that no less than 70% of the investment is in qualifying assets, this was not designed to 'catch inadvertent breaches'. Any that happened should be reported to HMRC together with a plan as to how the matter would be rectified. Mr Healey said that this was a 'small-scale problem' and HMRC would issue guidance to cover 'important aspects of inadvertent breaches'.
The reduction in tax relief from 40% to 30% was also discussed, with the Opposition putting an amendment to renew and make permanent the temporary 40% rate. Mr Healey said that when the temporary rate was introduced in 2002, it 'could not have been made clearer that it would expire on 5 April 2006. It was intended to stimulate venture capital trust investment and it had been successful in so doing. He noted that there had been record investment of £520 million in 2004-05 and £700 million in 2005-06. He said it would be 'unreasonable to expect the industry to continue this exponential growth and record fundraising every year'. Stability was now needed, and the Treasury's proposals would bring this.
The amendment was withdrawn.
Another Opposition amendment suggested that inheritance tax business property relief be introduced for venture capital trusts. However, ruling this idea out, Mr Healey said that income tax relief was the 'best incentive for investment in venture capital trusts' as it was available to the 'widest possible pool of investors' and inheritance tax would not be. He added that venture capital trust shares were quoted shares on the London Stock Exchange, whereas business property relief applied quoted shares only when they were still under family control. Thus it would not be compatible with the venture capital trust scheme.
The amendment was withdrawn.







