Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

News - direct news

19 June 2006
Categories: News , HMRC powers
The New Management Act; Guidance on direct tax disclosure regime; POA guidance amended; Gurkhas

Under new management

The creation of HMRC has generated the opportunity to review and the scope for integrating the administrative legislation for the main taxes. At the moment this is scattered through a number of Acts, is sometimes inconsistent and arguably out of date.
The New Management Act project team is developing new legislation governing the administration of:

  •  VAT;
  • income tax self assessment (including capital gains tax);
  • corporation tax self assessment;
  • pay as you earn and National Insurance contributions as operated by employers;
  • National Insurance contributions paid by the self-employed (Class 2 and 4 contributions).

The aim of the project is to create so far as possible a modern, simpler and more consistent legislative framework for the administration of taxes which is easier for our customers to understand and comply with and for the department to operate.
Within these five core schemes, HMRC are looking at common elements including registration and notification, returns and self assessment, payment and repayment, assessments, and claims. HMRC are also looking at time limits, appeals and other miscellaneous administrative provisions.
More information on the project is available on www.hmrc.gov.uk/nma/index.htm.
The ICAEW's Tax Faculty agrees that existing taxes management legislation should be reviewed and consolidated, saying that 'some of it is certainly showing its age and it can be hard to find'. However, it is concerned that the project is more than that, as HMRC say that they will also be making improvements. The Tax Faculty says that it is 'very important that any improvements which actually change the law should have proper public scrutiny'. HMRC have assured the Tax Faculty that the new management act project is liaising with the wider consultation on HMRC powers.


Disclosure

Guidance on the extended direct tax disclosure regime has been published by HMRC. It includes advice on:

  • tax arrangements relating to income tax, corporation tax and capital gains tax;
  • tax arrangements relating to stamp duty land tax;
  • the criteria for deciding if the tax arrangements are required to be disclosed to HMRC;
  • how to make a disclosure;
  • the systems HMRC expect users of tax arrangements to have in place to monitor for arrangements that they may potentially need to disclose to HMRC, rather than the promoter; and
  • how to notify HMRC that a disclosed tax arrangement is being used.

This guidance replaces and supersedes all previous relevant guidance with effect from 1 August 2006.
The three key changes which have effect from 1 August 2006, as opposed to 1 July as originally planned, are:

  • For income tax, corporation tax and capital gains tax purposes, the range of disclosable tax arrangements is no longer limited to employment or financial products. Under the revised rules, they potentially include any tax arrangement relating to any aspect of those taxes.
  • For income tax, corporation tax and capital gains tax purposes, the range of disclosable tax arrangements is no longer limited by a series of filters. Instead a tax arrangement becomes disclosable if any one of a series of 'hallmarks' applies.
  • Disclosure of newly implemented 'in-house' tax arrangements relating to income tax, corporation tax and capital gains is now due within 30 days of implementation, rather than by the filing date for the return period in which the first transaction of the tax arrangement was implemented.

There are no changes to the rules for disclosing tax arrangements relating to stamp duty land tax.
The guidance extends the rules beyond just employment and financial products, says Francesca Lagerberg of Smith & Williamson, therefore advisers will 'need to check that they are disclosing all they should, as direct tax now follows the VAT idea of “hallmarks” of avoidance'. She adds that the main change is introducing 'concepts that seek to capture packaged schemes. Clearly, HMRC believe that there are still schemes to capture and that there is revenue to be saved'. With regard to in-house schemes, Francesca notes that 'these must be reported within 30 days rather than on relevant returns, which will be a challenge for businesses'.
www.hmrc.gov.uk


Pre-owned assets

HMRC's pre-owned asset detailed guidance has been amended. It includes updated guidance on the treatment of loans and cross refers to the additional technical material contained in the Code of Practice 10 letter which can be found on the STEP/CIOT websites.
HMRC have now confirmed that loans to enable someone to acquire property do not satisfy the contribution condition which is very welcome. It also contains new sections on: reservation of benefit issues in connection with home loan schemes (HMRC's view); land — meaning of occupation; valuation; post-death variations of an estate.
New examples are given in a number of areas including: the de minimis exemption; calculating the benefit subject to the charge; reasonable attribution; sales at undervalue and double charges.
HMRC also comment on what happens re the pre-owned asset charge when a person subject to the charge moves home during the five year valuation period. Malcolm Gunn of Squire, Sanders and Dempsey says 'This huge tome of guidance is designed to shore up what is probably the most pernicious tax of recent years. HMRC offer their ”interpretations” (i.e. bending of the rules) on tricky points, but the new comments on the original double trust scheme will cause most alarm; the scheme does not work say HMRC, and yet is still caught for the income tax charge! Definitely no bending of the rules to help out there!'
Emma Chamberlain, barrister says that the revised guidance and flow charts are useful and show that HMRC have listened to some of the points made by the representative bodies. She questions though whether the pre-owned asset tax was ever needed in the first place in the light of the major inheritance tax changes contained in Sch 20: the charge just causes an unnecessary complexity. She notes that HMRC are still not accepting home loans where the loan is repayable on demand although their view has yet to be tested in the courts She also mentioned that Eversden schemes will be outside the pre-owned asset charge if the assets are appointed back in favour of the spouse and this is helpful in avoiding double inheritance tax charges if there is a death within seven years.
However, the news is not good with regard to equity release schemes, as they continue to be within the pre-owned asset charge, even if there is a sale (post March 2005) between members of the family at full value. In her view this can have some very unfair results and has no logic. The Paymaster General has remained firmly opposed to any change in this area. (See recent Standing Committee debates.)
www.hmrc.gov.uk


Gurkhas

Crown servants posted abroad continue to be chargeable to UK income tax on their earnings wherever they are serving. ITEPA 2003, s 28(5) to (8) were introduced to remove from the scope of UK income tax locally engaged low paid staff employed overseas by the Crown, in accordance with long-standing practice and in keeping with international treaty obligations. Changes to the Brigade of Gurkhas mean that it is no longer appropriate for Gurkhas to be treated differently from other members of HM Forces for tax purposes when serving overseas which is why this change is being made to the order.
The Social Security (Categorisation of Earners) (Amendment) Regulations 2006 (SI 2006 No 1530) and the Social Security (Categorisation of Earners) (Amendment) (Northern Ireland) Regulations 2006 (SI 2006 No 1531) amend the disregard that currently prevents the payment of NI in respect of Queen's Gurkha officers and any other member of the Brigade of Gurkhas of a person who was recruited for that Brigade in Nepal.
The order took effect on the day it was signed on 13 June 2006.
www.hmrc.gov.uk

Categories: News , HMRC powers
back to top icon