Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

News - direct news

17 July 2006
Categories: News , HMRC powers , Income Tax
31 January returns; Interventions pilot

31 January returns

31 January is to be the filing date for personal self assessment tax returns filed electronically and 31 October for paper returns, announced Lord Carter of Coles at the Tax Faculty's Wyman Symposium on 10 July. In his review of HMRC's online services published on 22 March 2006, Lord Carter recommended that the filing dates for income tax self-assessment returns should be changed from 31 January to 30 November for e-filed returns and to 30 September for paper returns. The Government accepted these proposals but offered a period of consultation on the implementation of Lord Carter's recommendations generally. See also this week's Comment, page 424, by Paul Aplin.
Various professional bodies held a number of meetings with HMRC and HM Treasury over the past three months and conducted a survey of members to obtain statistical evidence to demonstrate the likely effect that the change of filing dates would have. Lord Carter asked to see the new evidence and met representatives of the bodies to discuss it in detail. In light of this evidence Lord Carter has revised his recommendation to ministers. Many thanks are also due to the thousands of readers who supported Taxation's 'No to November' campaign.
The professional bodies add that they fully support the Government's stated policy objective of increasing the take up of HMRC's e-services and endorse Lord Carter's statement that countries with a high take up of online services attribute a large degree of their success to working with agent and software developers. The professional bodies are ready to participate actively in the pursuit of this objective. They believe that Lord Carter's recommendation that HMRC should build in more rigorous testing and if necessary delay the implementation date for a particular service is critical to successful delivery of the Government's policy objective. They welcome the statement in the regulatory impact assessment issued on 22 March 2006 that 'the success of the proposals will be constantly monitored and evaluated' and believe that this process should be achieved by close co-operation with key stakeholder groups.
Unrepresented and non IT literate taxpayers and small firms of tax agents who may need to file paper returns and who find themselves without the necessary information at 31 October, will face difficulties in meeting the new deadline. The professional bodies therefore wish to continue discussions with HMRC to explore ways in which such people can be helped to meet their filing obligations.
Paul Aplin, deputy chairman of the Tax Faculty, welcomed Lord Carter's announcement, saying that his statement 'vindicated the process of discussion and dialogue that we have pursued with HMRC, HM Treasury and Lord Carter himself over the last three months'.
George Bull of Baker Tilly welcomes Lord Carter's announcement that he listened to the evidence provided in response to his original recommendations to shorten tax return deadlines. He praises 'Lord Carter's open-mindedness in revisiting his original proposals and his courage in accepting and responding to constructive criticism'. Similarly, Peter Penneycard of PKF says, 'It is very brave of Lord Carter to admit that he had underestimated the impact the proposals would have had on taxpayers and their advisers but we are glad he has'.
Mr Bull adds that the Carter review has 'focused attention on a number of aspects of HMRC's practice which can be improved. Improvements in these areas would benefit HMRC in many ways, not least:

  • simple efficiency in its processes
  • reducing the delays and frustrations that afflict HMRC's 'customers' namely the taxpayers
  • improving the quality of tax compliance by developing a spirit of cooperation and support towards taxpayers who set out honestly to meet their obligations'.

He said that HMRC and their technology partners must now 'produce a system which is technically robust and reliable enough to handle online filing and has the capacity to cope with the expected high peak volumes of submissions'.
E-filing has advantages for all, but it must be 100% efficient to encourage taxpayers and advisers to use it. As Mr Penneycard says, 'to date, HMRC's record of shaky and incomplete systems has discouraged taxpayers from e-filing but with the common sense approach that Lord Carter is taking in auditing the project there is a much better chance that e-filing will deliver the speed and security we all want. If it does, taxpayers will use it'.


More on interventions

HMRC have published a note about the interventions pilot, which has already been the subject of some discussion, see for example, Update, Taxation, 6 July 2006, page 370.
The text of the note follows:

'From July 2006, HMRC will trial some new compliance interventions. These approaches are being developed to provide a broader range of risk based interventions which focus on simpler, less time-consuming ways of helping our customers make sure they pay the right amount of tax. We want to give taxpayers information relevant to their circumstances, and help them get things right, while avoiding unnecessary bureaucracy. In many cases, these new approaches will avoid the need for a full-scale enquiry, which can sometimes be expensive and time-consuming.
'Those selected for inclusion in the small-scale trials are selected on the basis of an identified risk. They are being asked to take part on a voluntary basis. If taxpayers choose not to take part in the trial they will not automatically be subject to an enquiry or employer compliance review or VAT assurance visit. However a risk will still exist and is likely that a proportion of those customers will be selected for a compliance intervention. Any enquiry would be opened formally at that point.
'It is also possible that a full enquiry, VAT assurance visit or employer compliance review may be necessary for a small number taxpayers who take part in the trials and are found to have made significant errors or have complicated affairs where a more formal approach is more appropriate. Taxpayers and their agents will be made aware of any need to enter into another compliance intervention as soon as it becomes evident.
'Agents will be copied in on all letters sent to clients, and, where an individual has a tax agent, any telephone contact initiating an intervention will be made to the agent.'

In a sense, says John Whiting of PricewaterhouseCoopers, HMRC are doing nothing new. While it is a pity that HMRC is beginning this new initiative before the review of their powers is concluded, they using existing powers, but perhaps trying to target them more effectively. However, he says that people tend to become anxious when they are contacted by HMRC, so it is important that the reason for the contact is clear and that the person contacted is made aware of his rights and obligations. He will 'watch with interest' to see HMRC's ultimate goal.
www.hmrc.gov.uk

Categories: News , HMRC powers , Income Tax
back to top icon