Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Appeals for all

25 September 2006
Categories: News

Appeals for all

How to reform the system of tax appeals to the best advantage of unrepresented taxpayers with limited means to pursue an appeal is the subject of report recently published by the Low Incomes Tax Reform Group.

Appeals for all

How to reform the system of tax appeals to the best advantage of unrepresented taxpayers with limited means to pursue an appeal is the subject of report recently published by the Low Incomes Tax Reform Group.
Robin Williamson of the LITRG says that unrepresented appellants face a number of barriers including 'the complexity of the tax system and of the appeals process; lack of clear guidance on how to prepare and present an appeal; absence of case management facilities; the risk of an onward appeal by the revenue authority and exposure to an adverse costs order'.
The report makes several recommendations designed to answer the practical needs of unrepresented appellants. These include:

Simple and direct access. Appeals should be lodged directly with the Tribunals Service; the process must be seen to be independent. HMRC should not interpose themselves as an intermediary between appellant and tribunal. The first tier tribunal should retain its existing local base.
Guidance and case management. There should be good, local case management facilities from the moment the appeal is lodged; appellants should be sent information about the appellate body and its contact details so they do not have to rely on HMRC to progress the appeal. The process should be subject to the overall supervision of a tribunal member in that the papers in each case would cross their desk at least once.
Finality. Unrepresented appellants should be able to rely on the decision of the first tier being final in most cases, but where there is an onward appeal they must be protected against an adverse costs order in all but exceptional cases.
Support for advice and representation. Consideration should be given to incorporating in the early preparatory stages of an appeal an opportunity for an unrepresented appellant to receive independent professional advice on the merits of their appeal. Good advice at an early stage saves costs later on.
Review of administrative decisions. Tribunals should be able to review administrative decisions made by Government departments where there is no statutory right of appeal, as has been proposed in draft legislation. Meanwhile, an independent body should be able to review cases where HMRC do not follow their own published guidelines, or exercise their discretion unfairly or incorrectly.

 

Categories: News
back to top icon