Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Unwelcome aggression

19 October 2006
Categories: News

Unwelcome aggression

Unwelcome aggression

The CIOT and the ICAEW Tax Faculty, both members of the Confédération Fiscale Européenne, jointly hosted the CFE General Assembly and associated events in London recently. HMRC's Dave Hartnett was one of the speakers and he looked at various areas including corporate responsibility from a business perspective. He was pleased to see that corporates are beginning to recognise value of good relationship with HMRC and said that businesses should be proud of their achievements. Mr Hartnett acknowledged that, 'if attitudes to avoidance/evasion are to change, tax administrations themselves had to change in order to create the right environment for compliance. However, in order to achieve that environment it is perhaps the tax advisers who sell aggressive avoidance schemes who need to change most of all. These advisers make a profit by selling these schemes — driving a wedge between the corporates and tax administrations'. Readers of some other sections of the press might be forgiven for thinking that he was referring to any adviser when he was in fact referring to those who market the aggressive avoidance schemes, so loathed by HMRC. As Francesca Lagerberg, chairman of the Tax Faculty said, it all comes back to the question 'what is acceptable tax avoidance?'
It has also been widely reported that Chris Spooner of HSBC said that it was not out of the question that HSBC would consider relocating away from the UK to a more competitive tax regime. Again, to put this into context, the point being made was that large corporates have to justify their location every now and then. As Chiltern points out, the UK tax regime is not perfect. For example, the legislation is increasingly complex, HMRC officials do not always seem to understand the world of commerce, and policy seems to lack cohesion. However, on the plus side, Chiltern points out that the UK has 'one of the best international tax treaty networks in the world' which 'enables companies to reduce their exposure to withholding taxes on interest, royalties and dividends'. The UK also has a good capital gains tax regime, having tried to 'catch up with the participation exemption available under such regimes as the Netherlands by introducing a substantial shareholdings exemption'. Although Chiltern considers the rules 'complex and unnecessarily restrictive', they improve the regime for holding companies significantly. Finally, Chiltern comments that membership of the EU has advantages with recent European Court of Justice decisions making it easier to operate cross border within the EU.
Thus Chiltern, while supporting the reform of corporation tax in the UK, concludes that 'any company contemplating a move offshore needs to look at the tax exposures in the round' and that it is 'a mistake' to think purely in terms of corporation tax, as all other taxes should also be taken into the equation.

Categories: News
back to top icon