Fiscal drag
Fiscal drag is undermining the credibility of the tax system, according to Baker Tilly's latest tax survey. Fiscal drag is the process by which governments do not increase tax exemptions and thresholds in line with inflation, so increasing the tax burden without having to introduce new taxes.
According to the results, 53% of accountants and 67% of legal professionals believe the fiscal drag has almost completely eroded the £8,500 employee benefit threshold (P11D) and should be updated. The survey also explored people's attitudes towards HMRC's responsibility to calculating a business's or individual's tax liability. 67% of respondents felt that HMRC should be responsible for calculating an individual's tax liability while 57% felt HMRC should be responsible for calculating a business's tax liability.
Another aspect of the research looked at recent Government proposals to align company accounts and tax return filing deadlines, with 32% saying that realignment would be too difficult to adjust to. Only 15% of respondents believed that the Government's proposals would reduce red tape for business.
Baker Tilly's George Bull says that instead of forcing businesses to change their systems, the Government would achieve more by 'encouraging firms to file their corporation tax returns electronically, and earlier'.
Missed opportunity
A worldwide forum of tax authorities intended to exchange ideas and set policy on international tax affairs has failed to address the most basic problem of tax administration, i.e. lack of trust between taxpayers and governments, according to KPMG International.
The forum, which took place in September in Seoul, Korea, under the auspices of the OECD Centre for Tax Policy Administration, brought together heads and deputy heads of tax authorities from 35 countries.
In its declaration, the forum set out a series of measures, including better cross-border exchange of information on tax planning schemes, and an international review of the role of intermediaries in tax planning, intended to improve the enforcement of national tax law.
But despite acknowledging that a factor in attitudes towards paying tax is the level of trust between taxpayers and their governments, the forum offered no ideas on how this trust gap can be closed. Nor, despite identifying that tax administrations are hard pressed due to growing commitments and resource constraints, did it acknowledge the extra costs associated with constant conflict with taxpayers.
'A failure to close the trust gap simply puts more pressure on tax administrations', said Loughlin Hickey, KPMG's global managing partner for tax. 'This meeting offered a real opportunity to signal an intent to explore ways to bring governments and taxpayers together. Both have an interest in sustainable growth stimulated by private sector investment, often from foreign sources, and government programmes funded by tax revenues. Tax intermediaries share this interest and have a key role in enabling taxpayers to comply with ever more complex legislation.
'Instead, the Seoul declaration paints a picture of non-compliance as something outside the law, while acknowledging that tax minimisation is legitimate, it brands an undefined part of legitimate planning as unacceptable. There is a case to be made for restraint in tax planning (through a code of conduct for example) but this cannot proceed in an atmosphere where tax administrations assert that they are the arbiters of what constitutes compliance and acceptability.'
'Multinational corporations are actively shopping around the world for the best deal on taxation', said Mr Hickey, 'and the governments that realise this are redrawing their corporate tax systems to encourage inward investment'. He said that organisations, such as the OECD, should sponsor the view that a purely legalistic approach to tax law design and revenue collection was not enough. Discussion between taxpayers, tax intermediaries and tax authorities worldwide were needed to rebuild the trust necessary for the efficient administration of the tax system, which should be aligned to a wider economic purpose than simple tax collection.
A CASE for cash?
An article on AccountingWEB by Nichola Ross Martin has triggered a call for a campaign to allow Cash Accounting for Small Enterprises — 'CASE'.
Following the well-publicised problems with UITF 40, the effect of accounting standards on taxable profits has become a hot topic. However, the complexity of even the rules which apply to smaller entities are not well-suited to the needs of small sole traders who simply want to agree how much tax they owe. Following up a suggestion on a previous item from contributor Martin Foley, Nichola Ross Martin therefore suggests that small businesses should be able to submit tax computations based on cash accounting only. The turnover limit for doing so should, she suggests, be lower than that for VAT cash accounting; set perhaps at somewhere between £50,000 and £75,000.
'If businesses adopted this method, they would no longer be at the mercy of the international accounting standard setters, there would be no UITF 40 and no problems in trying to decide whether to adopt UK or International Standards', she concludes.
Subsequent discussion has argued for and against some provision for accruals and prepayments where they are significant, considered whether cash accounting should be limited to unincorporated businesses or extended to companies as well, and looked at the possibility of cash accounting for capital items also.
Taxation would like to hear readers' views on this subject; please email them to us at taxation@lexisnexis.co.uk. We also have a poll on the front page of our website asking for your views — please go to www.taxation.co.uk and vote.
www.accountingweb.co.uk







