Speculative penalties
The weekend papers recently have been full of stories that the penalty for late filing of self assessment tax returns are to be increased from £100 to £250 (see The Sunday Times,29 October and The Telegraph, 11 November). However, when approached by Taxation, an HMRC press spokesman said, 'no decisions have been taken on the potential levels of penalties as the consultation process is still ongoing'. He added that 'it is important to note that the consultation document on HMRC powers which closed on 1 November is solely on criminal powers and should not be confused with a separate review of civil penalties. Consultation on non-criminal sanctions generated broad support for the framework proposed in March this year but nothing whatsoever has been decided yet. The whole process is open and transparent and we continue to work very closely with stakeholders, who are very supportive of the process.
'The principles underlying the consultation are to support those who seek to comply and deter those seeking an advantage by not playing by the rules. This means no penalties for mistakes or misinterpretations after reasonable care has been taken and possibly a graduated penalty, which reflects the seriousness of the taxpayer's behaviour. Any penalties would be substantially reduced or even waived if the taxpayer makes a full disclosure in order that the correct tax can be calculated.'
Commenting that the news stories in the national press seemed to be 'speculation', John Whiting of PricewaterhouseCoopers said that such an increase in the late filing penalty could, however, be 'plausible', although it would not go to the nub of the problem, i.e. why people do not meet the filing deadline. He thought that rather than simply jack up the penalty, it was important to find out 'why people are late in filing their returns', for instance, it could be that the system was too complex, in which case higher penalties were not the answer.
Despite the insistence that no decisions have yet been reached, Taxation expects the leaked figures wil turn out to be correct.
Board and lodging
HMRC have recently launched a consultation to identify a fair and effective way for owners of hotels and guesthouses to account for non-business expenditure for purposes of income tax self assessment. This does show that HMRC have heeded such owners and their pracititioners' concerns that the withdrawal of local arrangements would cause problems. See Update, Taxation, 1 June 2006, page 236 and 3 August 2006, page 491.
HMRC's objective is to identify a fair and effective way for hoteliers to account for non-business board and lodging expenditure for tax purposes that will:
- enable hoteliers to complete their annual tax returns accurately without unnecessary or disproportionate administrative costs;
- enable HMRC to deal with the tax affairs of hotel owners in an efficient manner;
- ensure that hoteliers are treated equitably and fairly in different parts of the country.
The consultation seeks taxpayers' views on the three following options:
- Option 1: Do nothing — end all local agreements.
- Option 2: Introduce a new local system for non-business adjustment on a permanent basis.
- Option 3: Replace local agreements with a single national regime.
Further details on each of these options can be found in the draft operational impact assessment on HMRC's website.
The views of hoteliers and their representatives are sought on each of the proposed options, in particular with regard to the following issues:
- whether they currently make use of a local agreement in completing their tax return;
- where they currently make use of a local agreement, whether they use a tax adviser or other agent to complete the tax return;
- how beneficial such agreements are in terms of time and costs;
- whether they anticipate that a particular option would be more difficult than others to operate in practice and why;
- whether a new set of locally administered agreements would be more or less equitable than a national regime.
Responses should be sent by 18 January 2007 to: Ruth Curtice, CT and VAT, HMRC, 100 Parliament Street, London SW1 2BQ, e-mail: ruth.curtice@hmrc.gsi.gov.uk.
Forces allowance
New regulations have been introduced to ensure that a new operational allowance (see Update, Taxation, 19 October 2006, page 58) announced by the Ministry of Defence can be paid to soldiers free of National Insurance. The Social Security (Contributions) (Amendment No. 6) Regulations 2006 come into force on the 14 November 2006. There will be similar tax and tax credits legislation in due course.
www.hmrc.gov.uk
Interest payments
An HMRC requirement adopted in 2003 with the intention of combating tax evasion by individuals on cross-border savings income has gone largely unnoticed, according to Smith & Williamson. Under the European Directive on taxation of savings in the form of interest payments, information is collected about the payment of savings income to residents in certain other countries and the details exchanged with the tax authorities in those countries.
Richard Mannion, national tax director at Smith & Williamson, says that it is to be expected that the regulations apply to banks, registrars and other financial institutions that make interest payments to individuals, but it is less obvious that they 'apply to accountants, solicitors and trust companies that hold money on behalf of individuals'.
For the period from 1 July 2005 to 5 April 2006, a return of interest payments covered by the regulations should have been submitted to HMRC by 30 June 2006, with penalties being imposed for failure to comply with the regulations, although Richard says that 'it is understood that HMRC are applying a light touch in this first year'.
Solicitors or accountants paying interest on a client account to an individual resident anywhere in Europe will be covered by the scheme and will need to inform HMRC that the new requirements apply to the firm. The contact address is: Chris Sexton, HMRC, Audit Unit (Information Returns), St Johns House, Merton Road, Bootle, Merseyside L69 9BB. HMRC will provide a form for completion and return. Any business unsure as to whether it is covered by the rules should refer to the savings income reporting guidance notes available on the HMRC website.
ECONs
An employer contracting out number is a reference number allocated to an employer who operates, or is part of a group of companies that operate, a contracted out pension scheme for their employees. Most employers only have one ECON and one PAYE reference number. However HMRC are aware that a number of employers believe that they need to submit National Insurance information using more than one ECON under one PAYE reference number, although only one contracting out number can be quoted on the P35.
Most cases arise as a result of mergers, acquisitions or transfers of undertakings so that the employer has ended up with employee under more than one contracting out number. This has occurred where one employer who has such a number takes over another employer with a contracted-out scheme. In such instances it is normally the case that the contracting out number of the company being taken over should be surrendered and that of the parent company/employer should be quoted on the P35.
Where a merger or acquisition has taken place it is important to keep everyone's records up to date. If the employer which has been taken over is to become a subsidiary of the new parent company, form CA7306 should be completed to update the contracting-out certificate of the parent employer accordingly. In addition, the contracting out certificate of the employer taken over should be surrendered.
However, if the employer that has been taken over is to become part of the parent company, form CA7313 should be submitted to surrender the contracting-out certificate.
In both of these circumstances, form CA1609 should be completed in respect of all current employees who were previously contracted out with the employer that has been taken over. This allows HMRC to update each employee's individual National Insurance account with the parent companies' contracting out number.
HMRC has a specific helpline, 0191 22 50264, for employers who believe they have more than one contracting out number.
www.hmrc.gov.uk







