Retail prices index
The all items retail prices index for December 2006 is 202.7.
Be afraid …
HMRC have published a further consultation document setting out how the Government proposes to update their criminal investigation powers and accompanying safeguards.
Under the new approach, HMRC's investigatory powers in England, Wales and Northern Ireland would be based on the Police and Criminal Evidence Act (PACE), while a statutory code would be introduced for Scotland, where PACE does not apply. This approach received broad support in the earlier consultation. As now, specifically authorised officers would be able to apply to the courts for search warrants and production orders, and exercise powers of arrest. Modernisation would harmonise these powers across all taxes and would mean that HMRC criminal investigations were subject to the statutory codes of practice and safeguards which attach to criminal investigations generally.
Criminal investigation powers are only available to the specialist teams in HMRC who actually undertake criminal investigation work. They are not available to other HMRC staff undertaking routine assurance or compliance work. HMRC have reorganised recently to ensure a clear separation between the criminal investigation work and all its other responsibilities which affect the vast majority of taxpayers. The changes set out in the clauses would reinforce the separation and specifically restrict access to these statutory powers to specialist officers authorised by the Commissioners of HMRC.
HMRC specifically invite and welcome consultative meetings with interested parties to discuss the approach and the draft clauses in detail. The deadline for submitting comments is 13 March 2007.
Proposals to extend HMRC's statutory powers to apply for surveillance warrants under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, to help combat serious tax crime by making HMRC's existing surveillance powers available against a wider range of criminal tax activity, are included in the Serious Crime Bill published on 17 January 2007. This takes forward proposals set out in an earlier HMRC consultation document published in March 2006.
Harry Travers, of BCL Burton Copeland solicitors, a member of the Tax Investigations Practitioners Group of the ICAEW, and was one of those responsible for drafting the ICAEW's TAXREP 32/06 in response to HMRC's last consultation document on criminal powers published in August 2006, said that he was disappointed in the latest consultation document. He says:
'We argued strongly [in TAXREP 32/06] that under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, interference of any sort with a person's right to respect for private and family life is only permitted if it is "necessary in a democratic society ... for the prevention of disorder or crime". That applied both to the proposed power of arrest (together with the various powers of search which come with it under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984) to be given to HMRC when investigating ex-Inland Revenue matters, and indeed to the clauses contained in the Serious Crime Bill published on 17 January which, if enacted, will extend the powers contained in the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act ("bugging powers") to HMRC when carrying out its ex-Inland Revenue functions.
'Furthermore, we argued that if HMRC's criminal investigation powers were to be expanded, there ought to be an independent judicial enquiry to consider whether this was necessary, which could take evidence from HMRC as to why they thought all this was necessary, as well as from interested parties — something like the Keith Committee in the early 1980s. We also pointed out that a number of Customs and Excise prosecutions have spectacularly and famously collapsed in recent years due to the abuse by officers of their powers, and not because their powers were inadequate.
'In fact, there was no independent review of the powers, and HMRC have proposed their own increased powers.
'HMRC have not accepted that they need to provide evidence as to why they need these powers, nor less provided any evidence — other than to say they need them for tax credit fraud, one small category of fraud which is atypical of direct tax fraud, as it generally involves wholly non-commercial activity.
'This is a disappointing response. They pay lip-service to the notion that the proposed legislation has to be European Convention compliant, but in fact they have not complied with it in proposing increased powers, when these are not necessary to investigate and prosecute direct tax fraud.
'Particularly in the current environment, where many suspect they are trying to shift the dividing line between tax avoidance and tax evasion, there is great concern that the criminal investigation and prosecution of direct tax fraud will not be conducted responsibly as before. If that happens we may see a loss of public confidence in the investigation and prosecution of this type of fraud, as we have done in recent years in relation to indirect tax fraud.'
www.hmrc.gov.uk







