2006-07 PAYE returns
HMRC has announced that some employers using aggregation when calculating National Insurance for their employees will get error messages 7130 and/or 7140 when they send their return to HMRC electronically. This is due to incorrect validation for 2006-07. A workaround is available by entering £1.00 in column 1c on the P14 of the affected employee(s).
HMRC say that EDI users should contact their account manager as advised by their acknowledgement report.
HMRC 'hope to have the correct validation in place for 2007-08 returns'.
www.hmrc.gov.uk
HMRC guidance
Charities
The detailed guidance notes for charities about charitable expenditure have been completely revised, updated and re-titled to reflect the provisions introduced by FA 2006 concerning the treatment of non-charitable expenditure and transactions with substantial donors.
Films
HMRC have published final guidance regarding claims for film tax relief.
www.hmrc.gov.uk
Discounted gift schemes
Guidance on discounted gift schemes has recently been published by HMRC.
In this latest guidance, HMRC say that the approach they are adopting in joint settlor cases is more precise than before, but that they have not made any fundamental change to their overall approach towards such trusts. They confirm that alternative approaches may be used to arrive at 'broadly similar results' and that they will be 'open to considering and agreeing alternative valuation bases that achieve that aim'. HMRC have clarified their stance in three areas:
- They have specified the methodology that providers should use in the valuation of gifts. This is crucial for determining the discount available on a discounted gift trust and therefore affects the amount of inheritance tax payable. HMRC have confirmed that the value of the gift will be based on the settlor's sex, age, health and insurability as at the gift date. They have also outlined their current assumptions on mortality and interest rates for this purpose.
- HMRC have outlined the technically correct methodology for valuing joint settlor cases. Whereas previously in joint cases, typically husband and wife, many providers assumed that the discounted value of a gift could be shared equally between the two individuals, i.e. 50:50, HMRC have confirmed that the technically correct approach is to value each individual's discount based on their own sex, age, health and insurability as at the gift date. In effect, this means that the correct discount will be allocated to the correct settlor. However they do 'not propose to re-open cases where the values transferred have been accepted in accordance with our previously adopted approach'.
- HMRC have confirmed the requirement that full whole life underwriting should be carried out for discounted gift trusts.
Colin Jelley, head of tax and financial planning at Skandia, says that the guidance provides 'clarity for advisers' and welcomes the fact that HMRC have consulted on the changes before implementing them. He welcomes the fact that a more standard approach to calculating discounts in the industry is to be taken, 'as it is going to make things more straightforward for advisers'.
The new standards come into force from 1 June 2007.
www.hmrc.gov.uk
Complaint, anyone?
HMRC have recently published a new factsheet 'Complaints and putting things right' which replaces the old Code of Practice 1 'Putting things right. How to complain' and notice 1000 'Complaints and putting things right'.
Naturally, Taxation wondered whether the information on the new factsheet differs much from the previous wording in COP 1 and notice 1000. This was not easy initially since, inevitably, the latter publications have disappeared from HMRC's website. However, on finding a copy of the old code, the most obvious difference is the volume of information. The old code was considerably longer, giving more information and telephone numbers while the new factsheet really gives the barest information possible. For example, while it also refers to the Adjudicator, it does not give her telephone number or Internet address, on the basis that complainants are supposed to exhaust all avenues with HMRC before approaching her and that when that point comes, HMRC say 'we will tell you how to do this when we give you our final decision'. By contrast, COP 1 gave the Adjudicator's postal address, telephone and fax numbers, e-mail and website. Internet addresses are given for the Ombudsman, Citizens Advice Bureau and the Independent Police Complaints Commission, but no telephone numbers or postal addresses.
The new guidance will be scrutinised in a longer article in the next issue of Taxation.
www.hmrc.gov.uk
NI disclosures
The tax avoidance disclosure regime is extended to National Insurance with effect from 1 May 2007. Following on from the full guidance published on 23 March, HMRC have published a short guide to payroll professionals explaining the basic mechanics of how the regime applies. Highlights follow, but see www.hmrc.gov.uk/aiu/nics-disclosure.htm for the complete version.
HMRC explain that the regime is designed to capture new and innovative schemes, but add that the 'disclosure regime is not a clearance system'.
The obligation to disclose normally falls upon the promoter, although in some circumstances, scheme users have to disclose rather than the promoter, e.g. where the scheme is designed in-house. Disclosures must be made within five days of making the scheme available for implementation.
A promoter disclosure does not identify clients. HMRC issues a scheme reference number which a promoter must pass on to clients, who then have to notify HMRC. For National Insurance schemes, the client will normally be the employer, who, if they use the scheme, must notifiy HMRC on form AAG4 by the filing date of the PAYE return affected.
A promoter who fails to disclose a scheme may be liable to a penalty, as will a scheme user who fails to notify.
A person who has to disclose a scheme for both tax and NICs can make a single disclosure. The only change after 1 May 2007 is that they must now explicitly explain how the scheme works for National Insurance. HMRC will issue a single scheme reference number.
As to the type of National Insurance schemes that must be notified, HMRC say that the 'starting point is that there must be a scheme' which is expected to provide someone with a reduction or deferral of payment of a National Insurance liability. Such a scheme is notifiable only if it falls within one of several 'hallmarks'. The hallmarks most likely to trigger a NICs disclosure are:
Confidentiality from other promoters. This is a hypothetical test — would any promoter want to keep that element confidential from other promoters in order to facilitate continued or repeated use of that element.
Confidentiality from HMRC. The test is would the promoter want to keep the element confidential from HMRC in order to facilitate continued or repeated use of that element.
Premium fee. The test is whether it is likely that any promoter would expect to receive a premium fee for the element that delivers the National Insurance advantage
Standardised NICs products. Exceptions exist for schemes that consist of certain statutory reliefs and for schemes made available before 1 August 2006
There has been some confusion over what constitutes a scheme. In this respect, HMRC say that although 'nothing specifically excludes salary sacrifice arrangements, or schemes that use salary sacrifice to provide other tangible benefits, from disclosure, they expect very few such schemes to be notifiable because they will fall out at some stage of the tests described above'.
HMRC say that childcare voucher schemes are an example of an existing standard scheme that we would not be expected 'to fall within the hallmarks'.
Peter Arrowsmith says that the guidance is 'mostly uncontroversial and not new' but is concerned that the date of 1 August 2006 is given in relation to the fourth hallmark, when the regulations are effective from 1 May 2007. This is potentially misleading if it is a mistake.
www.hmrc.gov.uk
Tax law rewrite
Draft clauses and explanatory notes on various topics in relation to the rewrite of corporation tax (Bill 5) have been published by HMRC for public consultation. Comments on the latest set of draft clauses are invited by 3 August 2007.
www.hmrc.gov.uk







