Bond washed
Bond washed
Earlier this year, HMRC approached a small number of charities, charitable common investment funds and professional advisers to establish whether they had incurred, or their clients may have incurred, any liabilities under the bond-washing legislation; see the Update report, Taxation, 8 March 2007, page 268. As a result of constructive discussions with these charities, it has become clear that the risk of liability in this area is less than had been thought. HMRC and the charities concerned are working to resolve any outstanding issues as quickly as possible, and at minimum cost to the charities involved. In the few cases where there is a potential tax liability, it is clear that the liability arose inadvertently and the charities were not expecting such liabilities to arise. In these circumstances HMRC will be considering in-date tax years only. Contrary to some press reports, HMRC say that they will not be seeking penalties. There may be some liability to interest where tax is paid later than it ordinarily would have been.
HMRC will not be extending this initial exercise any further, but will continue to monitor the operation of charitable tax reliefs to ensure that these are not abused.
This work on bond-washing has suggested to HMRC that there are some issues around the application of the bond-washing legislation to charities that do need to be looked at in more detail, particularly where it is clear that tax avoidance was not the purpose of the transactions, and HMRC will be working with the charity sector over the summer on these issues.
www.hmrc.gov.uk
Fishy scheme
Self-employed share fishermen across the UK are to be allowed to pay their self assessment tax by direct debit. They are traditionally paid by cheque and/or cash for every catch without any deductions, and HMRC say that research shows that share fishermen tend not to save for tax and National Insurance, which can cause difficulty when the tax bill finally arrives. The share fisherman scheme, set up by HMRC, allows members to set aside 20% of money earned aside each month from every catch, helping them to pay tax and National Insurance on time and automatically at the end of the tax year.
In order to sign up for the scheme, a share fisherman has to sign a mandate which allows a bank account to be opened in his name. Tenders are issued by fishing industry and it selects the banks to take part in the scheme. This allows the boat owner to pay a slice of the fisherman's earnings into his bank account each month. In addition, the fisherman needs to sign a direct debit, which allows HMRC to take the money out of the account. HMRC know how much tax to collect by direct debit from the share fisherman's completed tax return. Normally the settling agent/owner of the boat would send the monies deducted from the catch proceeds direct to the bank monthly, but an individual could also operate the scheme for himself.
The benefits to owners are that if the crew member is up to date with his tax he is less likely to change vessel and the owner would have a more settled crew. Non UK crew are liable to UK tax and also can register for tax and NIC and to join the scheme.
As part of the scheme, share fishermen can also get tax relief on seakit expenses, currently set at £700 a year. The expenses, for fishing wear and gear, cover protective clothing, oil-skins, boots, gloves, stones and bedding.
HMRC add that share fishermen earning above £18,000 a year might have to pay a higher rate of tax than 20%.
HMRC explain how the scheme will work as follow:
- money is deducted by the fishing vessel owner and paid into an interest bearing account at one of two banks;
- the banks tell HMRC on spreadsheets what is in the accounts three to four weeks before 31 January and 31 July;
- HMRC manually review and then forward the amended spreadsheets to their Worthing office;
- HMRC key in the data from the spreadsheets to create a direct debit file which goes to collect the payment, and mainframe update file which updates the self assessment taxpayer records with payment.
It would, however, be helpful for many other taxpayers to be able to pay tax by direct debit, but this does not seem likely to happen on a more general basis at this stage. HMRC say that the share fisherman's scheme involves 'a lot of manual effort' and that therefore it 'could not offer the facility in its current state more generally'.
HMRC press release dated 21 May 2007
New approach
HMRC's litigation and settlements strategy is relevant to all aspects of how HMRC enter into, handle and settle disputes about any taxes, duties or credits. It sets out principles for bringing tax disputes to a conclusion, whether by agreement with the taxpayer, or by litigation, i.e. statutory appeal to an independent body, including the General or Special Commissioners, the VAT tribunal, or the courts.
The aim of the strategy is to ensure that HMRC conduct disputes in a way that is professional, effective and that supports HMRC's objectives to close the tax gap and provide taxpayers with a clear understanding of the law. The central themes are:
- to seek non-confrontational solutions where possible;
- to focus on issues that will best serve HMRC's goal of tax gap reduction;
- to choose cases for their wider impact, as well as for their own value;
- where HMRC have a strong case, they should seek full value from settlement, or take the matter to litigation;
- not to pursue weak arguments;
- to work cases with colleagues, including those in other parts of HMRC.
According to Grant Thornton, HMRC's new approach means that complex and international companies will be under more scrutiny than ever. 'If in the high risk bracket, companies are likely to see HMRC knocking on the door more frequently, with longer periods spent monitoring the books and immediate penalties imposed on anything out of line', says Grant Thornton's Paul Roberts. 'Other than financial risk, wider and potentially more harmful reputational risks can arise from tax queries, such as perceived failures of management to much more serious issues like criminal investigations by tax authorities and in the worst case, prosecution of directors', he added.
The complicating factors that may contribute to the risk level of a company could include company change, business complexity, boundary and cross-border issues and tax contribution. By changing their approach, HMRC believe that they will collect more tax and leave the compliant low risk businesses to earn more profits, resulting in more tax.
When rating the risk of a business, HMRC look at the business attitude towards risk issues, the nature of the business's compliance relationship with HMRC, the company's tax strategy, its reporting structures and the resourcing of the tax function. In terms of delivery, HMRC look at completion of returns and declarations, monitoring of internal processes, and the levels of supervision. In response to this new approach, Paul Roberts suggests companies take steps to self assess their position against HMRC's criteria. If a business wishes to reduce its risk rating, the first step is to establish the board's view on tax. 'Numerous questions should be considered for self assessment, concerning the tax fit with the business strategy, the aggressiveness of the board's appetite for tax risk, and more importantly its relationships with major tax authorities', he said. 'Essentially, a finance director should understand the difference between HMRC's view of tax risk and the commercial exposures, as part of the company's wider risk picture.'
Taxation will cover HMRC's proposed litigation and settlements strategy in more detail in an article in the 21 June issue.
www.hmrc.gov.uk







