Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Sharkey debate 'misled Parliament'

03 March 2009
Categories: News , Income Tax
Trade bodies did not ask for legislation, reveals barrister

MPs were ‘seriously misled’ in the run-up to the enactment of Schedule 15 to the Finance Act 2008, claims barrister Keith M Gordon.

In an open letter to Ian Pearson, the economic secretary to the Treasury, Mr Gordon criticises the handling of what is commonly known as the rule in Sharkey v Wernher.

Mr Gordon has long been a critic of the Sharkey decision by the House of Lords, which held that a trader who took stock for personal use should, for tax purposes, account for the profit that would have been generated had the items been sold in the course of business. (For more background, see the article The Sharkey bites back.)

In his letter, Mr Gordon begins by criticising the ‘shoddy and anti-business’ rule as ‘contrary to common sense, [creating] an unnecessary distinction between profits as calculated for accounting purposes and taxable profits, [deviating] from the position under VAT law and, generally, taxes businesses on profits that they have not made’.

He goes on to express his principal concern: that ‘Parliament was seriously misled during the course of the [Finance Bill 2008] debate’ about the Sharkey rule, and he highlights how Mr Pearson’s predecessor, Kitty Ussher, told the Finance Bill Committee:

'We have been asked to legislate on this by the normal types of body that one would expect: the trade associations and the accountancy and legal professions.'

Mr Gordon says that, as a member of the legal and accounting trades, he was ‘most surprised to learn of this’ and so sent the Treasury a Freedom of Information request for the names of the bodies that had asked for the Sharkey rule to be codified.

In a late-to-arrive response, the department admitted that no trade associations had demanded such legislation.

In which case, says Mr Gordon, Ms Ussher’s remark to MPs should have been:

‘We have not been asked to legislate on this by any of the normal types of body that one would expect: the trade associations and the accountancy and legal professions.  In fact, two [the CIOT and the ICAEW] have specifically objected to it.’ (Original emphasis.)

He concludes his letter (which can be read in full here) with the hope that, ‘Parliament will be given the respect it deserves and that a suitable clarification and correction will be made’.

Categories: News , Income Tax
back to top icon