Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration
Home Saved articles Viewed items Login Contact Free Trial Advertise View virtual issue View online issue

Open letter to the economic secretary to the Treasury

03 March 2009
Categories: Income Tax
Barrister Keith M Gordon criticises Sharkey Finance Bill debate

Dear Minister

I am writing concerning comments made to the Finance Bill Committee on 20 May 2008 by your predecessor, Ms Kitty Ussher (in particular at column 311 in Hansard).  The debate concerned the then proposal to enact a rule, commonly known as the rule in Sharkey v Wernher [1956] AC 58, in what is now Schedule 15 to the Finance Act 2008.

Shoddy and anti-business

The proposal was contrary to common sense, created an unnecessary distinction between profits as calculated for accounting purposes and taxable profits, deviates from the position under VAT law and, generally, taxes businesses on profits that they have not made.

However, given that it is the prerogative of Parliament to enact such legislation, irrespective of the views of business, I will not press this point any further.

Parliament was seriously misled during the debate

My principal concern, however, was the fact that Parliament was seriously misled during the course of the debate.  Given the seriousness with which Parliament takes such matters, I hope that this matter will be properly dealt with.  (I suspect that Ms Ussher was not deliberately intending to mislead the Committee.  However, my understanding of Parliamentary protocol is that this should not preclude the matter from being properly considered.)

Ms Ussher told the Committee:

We have been asked to legislate on this by the normal types of body that one would expect – the trade associations and the accountancy and legal professions.

As a member of both the accounting and legal professions, I was most surprised to learn of this and made a request under the Freedom of Information Act for the identification of those bodies that had asked the Treasury for this legislation.  (At the same time, I also asked for details of any of such bodies that had objected to the proposal.)

My FOI request was responded to late.  A cynic might suggest that this was to ensure that I would not receive a response until after Parliament had gone into recess last summer.  However, in the absence of any further information, I am prepared to accept the reason given to me that the Treasury’s e-mail system was flawed.

In the response, the Treasury advised me that there were in fact no trade associations that had made the request.  There were, however, three letters from the CIOT that the Treasury cited as justification for the Minister’s comments. It will be immediately clear from even a superficial read of those letters that the CIOT was not suggesting that the Sharkey v Wernher rule be codified.  Thus, to suggest that there had been any request for the change in the legislation from any legal or accounting body, is rather stretching the truth.  For a fuller discussion on the contents of those letters, I would refer you to my article on the AccountingWeb.

Furthermore, should any doubts remain, the CIOT was one of the two bodies (the other being the ICAEW) that the Treasury acknowledged to have objected to the proposal.

In short, the Minister’s comments should have read:

We have not been asked to legislate on this by any of the normal types of body that one would expect – the trade associations and the accountancy and legal professions.  In fact, two have specifically objected to it.

I trust that Parliament will be given the respect it deserves and that a suitable clarification and correction will be made. 

In addition, I can assure you that there will be very few people outside HMRC and the Treasury who would object to the repeal of Schedule 15.  That, however, as I have already noted, is a matter for Parliament.

Yours faithfully

Keith M Gordon MA(Oxon) FCA CTA(Fellow) Barrister
Atlas Chambers
3 Field Court
Gray’s Inn
London WC1R 5EP

cc
George Osborne MP
Vince Cable MP
Editor, Taxation

Categories: Income Tax
back to top icon