Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration

This week's opinion: 10 June 2021

08 June 2021 / Andrew Hubbard
Issue: 4795 / Categories: Comment & Analysis
Make research have an impact

An item in a recent RSM newsletter drew my attention to something I had not seen before: HMRC’s list of external research projects for 2021-22 (tinyurl.com/hmrcextres). I counted 34 items, which show the vast range of HMRC’s work – from Chinese online marketplace sellers to museum and galleries tax relief. 

Of more direct interest to readers will be two areas which create real difficulties for clients. The first is ‘exploring the tax challenges faced by “hybrid” taxpayers’ – those treated as individuals and businesses by HMRC. Over the years I have often discussed with HMRC the way that the self-employed can fall through the gap between the personal tax and business tax arms of HMRC. Self-employed workers fall into both categories, and often responsibility for them, both at policy and operational level, gets lost in the system. This is clearly a valuable area for research. 

The other area which caught my attention was ‘emerging contract trends in the labour market’, which is concerned with individuals whose work contracts allow them to set their own working pattern, and to accept or decline work being offered by their engager. This is a crucial area of the economy and I doubt that anybody, whether in government, HMRC or the profession, could say that our current tax system copes well with this massive shift in the labour market. 

I can imagine readers saying, ‘why bother with all this research – get on with fixing the problems’. I understand this, but I believe that many of the problems with the current system are as a result of decisions taken without proper analysis. So I support this work, but please, let it lead to action and not simply be a way of kicking problems into the long grass.

 

If you do one thing...

Read the new guidance on the extended loss-carry rules, in particular the mechanism for making early claims (tinyurl.com/hmrcelcbb). 

Issue: 4795 / Categories: Comment & Analysis
back to top icon